What is anal sex supposed to feel like? My boyfriend and I tried it, for the first time, the other night and we stopped after the second thurst because it was getting painful for me. But it also felt really weird (at least compared to normal sex). It was like I was "pooing" his penis out! I was just wondering what it's supposed to feel like? I love (normal) sex, I was just wondering if this was a "normal" feeling for anal.

Thanks

What you are feeling is a normal reaction.Some like it...some don't.
There is a slight possibility that anal sex does not feel "normal" for you because maybe, for you, it isn't.
Realize that the anus produces no lube at all and wasn't originally designed for sex by mother nature.
Attempting anal sex without lots of lubrication could be painful. If he is rather large, it could be painful, even with lube.
For you, vaginal sex might be best and working on more foreplay there might satisfy you better. You should never continue with a variation on sex that isn't comfortable with you.