Art work is subjective and your point about many designers/options and price ranges hits the mark.
The right choice for 1 person might not be the right choice for someone else. It really depends on your product, audience, budget, etc as to what you need (best of best or just best) and then you have to decide who to use.
For me turn around time and customer service would also be very important.
Free Do-It-Yourself Cover Art Tutorial