As I saw it, it's not that she *couldn't* charm Gollum, but that she didn't want to bother. After all, she didn't bother charming Gimli, either. Notice he's the only one not impacted by anything she does. Presumably she didn't find either of them interesting enough to charm.
Posted on Feb 20, 2004, 1:01 AM from IP address 165.228.132.11