<< Previous Topic | Next Topic >>  

Getting some real answers (if possible)

March 5 2004 at 9:59 AM
No score for this post
Sandy  (Login liturgist)
Moderators

 

Okay, so here is what I'm thinking.  Once before, we came up with some really great questions for JKR with the idea that we'd send one big board letter and see what sort of response we could get.  The hitch was that it never actually got mailed (Chris! ) and it was so close to the release of book 5 that we didn't actually expect a lot of response.

So, here is what I propose.  Let's try again.  I'll take on the job of getting the letter together and will get everyone's questions put together in what will be a organized fashion (I hope) and mail it off.  Let's use this thread for listing everyone's questions.

I'll leave this thread open for additions for two weeks.  That means you can add questions for the letter until March 21 (I'll give everyone that weekend to get things in).  After that, I'll put them together and mail them off.

Waddaya think?

 



~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~


http://www.schnoogle.com/authorLinks/Sandy_Phoenix
http://www.fanfiction.net/read.php?storyid=1461584

 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   
AuthorReply

(Login CPGKeyca)

Re: Getting some real answers (if possible)

No score for this post
March 5 2004, 10:38 AM 

The reason I like it is that you are far more responsible then me by a long shot. This one may actually get sent lol!!!

Okay, I think we should start this off by going threw the threads that were going around here with the questions that were not answered (or ones you are hoping for a better answer from). That would be a good start I think.

I think the next step would to be gather up the Message Board Theories threads that MadEye had going and pull them apart and see what questions we can get from them that havn't since been answered directly, or even indirectly.

Now in the mean time from pulling all of those together, I would like to make a sugestion to anyone writting a question. If in all likelyhood she is more likely to answer it indirectly rather then give the plot away, try and word it so you aren't looking for a direct answer but want clues or even ideas of when and where we can learn the answer to things. That's what I did with my vampire question (That wasn't asked!!!). I think I still want to add the question in. She practicaly said Snape is not a vampire, but the way mine was worded she could go a little further in explaining why all the hints are there then how she answered on the chat. That's just an example of what I mean about wording the question carefully.

Also, Sandy, when you send it I would sugest sending it to all of the fan addresses that Muggle Net has up (Where I got the address to send it to her in the first place). They had more then one address. This way it may be quicker for her to answer because for our luck you may send it to one address and it may take a month for her to receive it as apposed to another address which may take a week. Know what I mean?



http://www.keycasplace.tk

"Let's all play a game of hangman! Now who should we hang"? ~Riley

"If you don't finish that crud on your plate, you won't get any crap for desert" ~Dan on the show Roseanne

CPGKeyca = AIM
Keycas Place = AOL

 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   
Narcissa
(Login NarcissaMalfoy)
Moderators

Re: Re: Getting some real answers (if possible)

No score for this post
March 5 2004, 6:15 PM 

Brilliant idea Sandy, here's my questions:

Why had Fred and George never noticed Peter on the map? Scabbers was Percy's pet and Ron's.

How did Scabbers come to Percy's possession? Please tell me they didn't pay for that!

The other Slytherin boy who had seen the Thestrals in Hagrid's class - who had he seen die? (Was in Theodore Nott by chance?)

Is Blaise Zambini a boy or a girl?

Will the next DADA be a new character as tradition or will it be a character from before? (Lupin?)

Does Dumbledore keep relawney employed for her protection? Could Voldemort access the prophesy from her via Legilimency?

Is Snape a Pureblood?

EDIT: Narc, I hope you see this.  I recently had to look up Blaise Zabini in the Lexicon.  (All hail the Lexicon!) and due to some pronouns and the gender of some descriptors in some translations, they determined that Blaise is, indeed, a male student.  Personally, I'm not sure why this is a big mystery.  I do know a guy named Blaise.

 



~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~


http://www.schnoogle.com/authorLinks/Sandy_Phoenix
http://www.fanfiction.net/read.php?storyid=1461584


    
This message has been edited by liturgist on Mar 5, 2004 8:07 PM


 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   
MadEye
(Login MadEye)

Real Answers

No score for this post
March 5 2004, 8:06 PM 

So many questions, so little time.....This is a great idea, and I hope it works, however, I think the list of questions will need to be either reduced to a manageable number like 20 (ya, like 20 questions) or consolidated as Chris did with lots of questions rolled into a few big ones.  But I would leave that up to you Sandy, I'm sure you can do an excellent job with it.
 
Where was Harry during the missing 24 hours and who was he with during that time
 
Did Voldemort come alone to Godric Hollow to kill Harry
 
Could Dumbledore kill Voldemort if he chose to, or can ONLY Harry kill him
 
What is the true nature of the Dementors, what are they, how did they come into being.
 
Can one talk to the voices beyond the veil
 
 

 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   
Sandy
(Login liturgist)
Moderators

Re: Real Answers

No score for this post
March 5 2004, 8:10 PM 

Okay, I did an edit to Narc's post, but maybe I should just do a reply.

Narc, I mentioned what I read about Blaise.  MadEye, about the dementors... someone can double-check me and certainly, I will double check our questions against what she said in this latest chat interview, but I believe she said we would learn about the dementors in book 6.

 

 



~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~


http://www.schnoogle.com/authorLinks/Sandy_Phoenix
http://www.fanfiction.net/read.php?storyid=1461584

 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   

(Login CPGKeyca)

Re: Getting some real answers (if possible)

No score for this post
March 5 2004, 11:11 PM 

No, I don't think we should limit it to 20. It isn't like a 1 on 1 interview. She can sit down (and if she chooses to answer a single question, mind you), she can take the time to find the perfect answer for all of them to possibly satisfy us and not give everything away. I say don't have a limit because after all it isn't like a regular interview, she won't be on a time limit and she can put it down and walk away and answer them on her own schedule. Hell she can skip a question if she doesn't want to answer it.

http://www.keycasplace.tk

"Let's all play a game of hangman! Now who should we hang"? ~Riley

"If you don't finish that crud on your plate, you won't get any crap for desert" ~Dan on the show Roseanne

CPGKeyca = AIM
Keycas Place = AOL

 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   

(Login CPGKeyca)

Re: Re: Getting some real answers (if possible)

No score for this post
March 7 2004, 11:36 AM 

Okay, Sandy! Since nobody is looking at this thread, I'm gathering quesstions together myself to add to it. ...May I also sugest renaming this thread somthing like "Submit Your Questions to JK Now!" Or something along those lines.</P>

P.S. ...Sandy, would you mind just reading everything over before you add it, so I don't have any typos, since everybody likes to make a point in pointing them out to me lol?</P>

----------------------------------------------------------</P>

What happens to Animagi wizard's clothes? Does it transform with them? ~Narcissa~

Centaurs are considered half-human, half horse. What is the origin to that? ~Narcissa~

That question brings me to the tradition Giant question. Hagrid asked Maxime if it was her mother or father. CAN it be a father? :S ~Narcissa~ (I added this just to see if she will dare to humor us with an answer. If not then oh well.)
</P>

Mark Evans. Everybody I know who is into Harry Potter has discussed this one topic until I just want to kick them for bringing it up. I was surprised to see out of the most over talked about topic, it was not a question asked in the online chat you participated in. So, dispite so many people being sick of hearing other people talk about it (including myself), I'll ask just in hopes for something concreet enough to stop curiosety (And so I can tell people to stop talking about it since I would know the answer once you answered it.). What is the deal with that character Dudley beat up? Is he related in ANY way, shape, or form to Lily and Harry? Most people over look it since Harry was said to not have any relitives other then the Dursleys. But at the same time, the other half of people say you wouldn't put in a name that happens to be his mother's madin name (no matter how common a name it may be) without some form of a family tie we don't know about it yet. Are people reading way too much into it, or is this something we can expect to be answered? ~The Great Keyca~</P>

Was there any significance to the name Mark Evans? - The ministry said that Harry was the only wizard living in Little Whinging but would he have counted as a wizard as he is only 10? ~Michele Lupin~</P>

We know you are enjoying your time writting book 6, and we are happy to hear it. Enjoying writting the book will only make it a better read as apposed to something you havn't enjoyed writting. You also, at one point, said that it is just flowing right out of you (may have what you said a little different, which is why I didn't quote it...). Now, obviously not counting any other second or third drafts, and editing and everything after that, but how far into the book would you estimate have already written for your first draft? ~The Great Keyca~</P>

You have said that we would not need a prolouge to be written after you finish this series. Now my question is not about if we would need it or not, but what you want to do. I'm wondering if you would like to write one just for the additonal reading material? Kind of like a single book or evan a series based on the past Order of the Phoenix, and their attempts, or maybe Tom & Hagrid's stay at Hogwarts, or probably the one that more people would want, a story on James' stay at Hogwarts? Like I said, obviously not neccecery since you said we won't need one, but besides for what would be needed, would you be interested in doing something to that effect after the Harry Potter series is indeed concluded? ~Keyca, The Rambler...~</P>

Is Neville under a memory charm? ~Lilys_Eyes~</P>

Does Nevilles toad trevor have any particular use, other than his pet? ~Lilys_Eyes~</P>

What is Nevilles Uncle Algea like? ( He held Neville out a window, he can't be that great of a guy) Was he associated with the Death eaters? ~Lilys_Eyes~ ...(Lily, I changed "What he associated..." to "Was he associated..." because I figured that is what you meant.)</P>

Percy, & Scabbers. We were wondering why Hogwarts let Percy and also Ron bring Scabbers to school, since it is not either a cat, toad, or owl. Also, for a rat like Scabbers to come into possesion by a family like the Wheeslys, well that can't be an accident. That had to have happened for a reason other then coincedence. Are we correct at guessing that, and will we find anything out about that in time? ~Asked be Sevie, & Lilys_Eyes. Reworded by The Lousy Keyca since he lost the original question...~</P>

In the online chat you participated in, someone asked you if there would be a new Minister of Magic. My spin on the question is, would the Minister be from where Harry & Co. are from? I ask this because in Goblet of Fire I remember there being Ministers from each country. Now, to add to the question, this new Minister, any chance it's Mr. Wheesly? I ask because Ron has this untapped uncanny ability to seem to predict things. In the Mirror of Erised he saw himself with numerous things. He has now gotten all of them except for what he has yet to have the opertunity to occomplish. Then later on in Order of the Phoenix, Ron says that Gryfindore had as much of a chance at winning the Quidditch cup as his father did of becoming the next Minister. Forshaddowing, or coincedence? ...Before I end that question, I would like to also state that it said that a true seer is VERY rare, from what I've read in your books. Any chance Ron may be in the early stages of discovering a path to becoming a true seer? ~The Great Keyca~</P>

Could you please tell us something specific about Snape and his past that we don't already know? ~Sevie~</P>

Can I borrow a few million dollars? ~Sevie~</P>

I was wondering about some details in the feud ebtween Snape and Lupin. For example, would you care to shed some light on the whole vampire/werewolf subject? In a lot of stories, fictional and supposed legends, vampires and werewolves are considered enemies. Now we see a lot of points in your stories that sugest Snape being a vampire, that a lot of people have caught onto, and talk about online. My major part of this question is if we will find out one way or another in the stories if Snape is indeed a vampire. The other "layer" to this question is about how you, in your stories, have vampires and werewolves play out. Friendly, enemies, or like normal humans, depending on each personality and if they clash with each other when it comes to individuals. Now I'm not looking for a definate answer as to if Snape is a vampire, because if it is no or if it is a yes verdict would probably give away too much in your eyes. What I'm looking for is if we see in the books if that topic will be touched, if so then when and where, and if not then why not since their is so much evidence pointing as to he is. Now if it is a no he is not, I'm not looking for why isn't he one, but why throw so much in our face and then not even mention it once? ...I will say that that question was written by me and submitted to be used for the online chat, but was not used. Another person asked you about a connection with Snape and Vampires, and you answered it. But I feel I can still get a worth while answer from this question reguardless. I would also like to add to the question this: You tend to mention things, and then make them appear later on in the story, or later in the series. Vampires have been mentioned in the past, so I was wondering that even if Snape is not a vampire, will we see one or more before the series ends? ~Keyca~</P>

What can you tell us about Lily's wand?  In book one, when Harry first met Ollivander and purchased his wand, Ollivander said Lily's wand was good for charms work and James' was good for transfiguration.  We have seen how skilled James was (a self-trained animagus).  Did Lily have some specific skills with charms and, if so, what? ~Sandstorm Sandy~</P>

In book two, Professor Lockhart acts out curing a werewolf with the Homorphus Charm. You then said that all the things Lockhart said he had done had actually been done, only by different people, so does this mean there is a cure for werewolves and that there may be hope for Remus Lupin? ~Michele Lupin~</P>

About the marauders map, how does it know who to show on the map seeing as otherwise there would be over a thousand moving dots... also, how can you tell which floor someone is on if it is a birdseye view?If it isn't a birdseye view, how could you tell where abouts on a floor someone was? ~Michele Lupin~</P>

When is the next book out and what is it called? ~Everyone on the face of the planet...And Michele Lupin~</P>

If you were to give tips for someone to get into writing and getting their stuff published, what would it be? ~Michele Lupin~</P>

If Kreacher hated Sirius so much that he left when he was ordered but hadn't been given clothes, why hadn't he left before hand. It was said that a house elf can only leave when given clothes but Harry reminded them that Dobby left, so why hadn't Kreacher? ~Michele Lupin~</P>

Will Harry be continuing Occlumency in the next book? ~Michele Lupin~</P>

It has been said that the last word in the seventh book will be scar. Seeing an interview with you, you said that the last chapter of book seven is an epilogue to say what happened to all the characters afterwards, so is the last word of the epilogue scar, or is it the last word of the chapter before.... or, is the scar rumour just that, a rumour? ~Michele Lupin~</P>

Will Sirius's name ever be cleared despite the unfortunate fact that he's dead? ~Michele Lupin~</P>

Why did Fred and George never see the name Peter Petigrew on the Marauder's map when they had it in their posession, as Percy and Ron both had him at Hogwarts. ~Michele Lupin~</P>

Can Squibs really see dementors or was Mrs Figg lying? ~Michele Lupin~</P>

What else can a Squib do that a muggle can't? ~The Great Keyca~</P>

Do you ever look around the net to read the Fanfiction your fans have written about Harry Potter? Or visited any of the discussion boards to read what your fans think? ~Michele Lupin~</P>

With the last question being said, is there any fanfics you would recomend reading to pass the time in between book 5 & 6's release? I'm sure if you recomended a fic you thought decent enough to carry a name like Harry Potter that the author would be extatic (I don't write, so I'm not trying to suck up). Also, would you read a fanfic if it was sugested to you? <STRONG><EM>(Insert fanfics that board members have written here, Sandy, lol!)</EM></STRONG> ~The Great Keyca~</P>

Who will be the DADA in the next book? ~Narcissa~</P>

What is the title and aproximate length? ~Narcissa~</P>

Will there be more deaths? ~Narcissa~</P>

WHY did you kill Sirius? Couldn't you have killed Hermione instead?? ~Narcissa with half of the readers she has talked to waiting for a responce on ther Hermione half...~</P>

Why did they choose Dan to play Harry Potter? People picture Harry Potter as extremely scawney and well undernurished. Dan looks about average. Compaired to the actual Harry from description, Dan could almost be considered fat. ~LilMissMalfoy, The Great Keyca, & everyone else on the net who has seen the movie and isn't in love with either Dan or Tom...~</P>

Is Blaise Zabini male or female because i have got no idea... ~Idril.Tinuviel~</P>

Where did Hagrid take Harry for almost 24 hours the night Harry's parents were killed? ~Dad-Eye~</P>

How did Tom Riddle figure out that he was the heir and how did he find the chamber? ~Dad-Eye~</P>

When did the ministry start the Underage Magic Use act? Okay, I know this isn't a burning question, but the comments about Lily turning teacups into toads at home keeps coming up in our online conversations. ~Dad-Eye~ (Dad-Eye, I added ..."in our online conversations." to the end of your question so she doesn't missinterpret as she keeps bringing it up, which may confuse her since she doesn't lol.)</P>

How do muggle parents send gifts and letters to their kids at Hogwarts? Why did Hagrid use Hedwig, instead of any other owl, to send letters to Harry during the first year? Also, mail seems to be mostly sent and retrieved by the owl that belongs to that particular wizard. How does the owl know that someone has a letter for his master? ~Dad-Eye~</P>

How long had Quirrel been teaching DADA before Harry got there? ~Dad-Eye~</P>

What house was Dumbledore in when/if he attended Hogwarts? Was he in charge of any particular house when he was a teacher? What other teaching positions did he hold as a teacher, besides transfiguration? ~Dad-Eye~</P>

Have you met Danniel Radcliffe? Isn't he cute? <giggle> ~Dad-Eye~</P>

You had Lord Voldemort say in book one that both Harry and James were his target. In the fifth book, however, you leave James out of the prophecy and instead say that Neville was the other of Voldemort's possible targets. Is there a reason for this contradiction or was it even a contradiction? ~Helen Wulfgar~</P>

What do the gum wrappers mean. ~MadTacoQueen, or MadEye~</P>

Do all death eaters have the dark mark, and does Dumbledore check for the mark before admitting people to the Order. ~MadTacoQueen, or MadEye~</P>

What happens to the soul-sucked? ~MadTacoQueen, or MadEye~ ...Besides being elected or appointed to government? ~Added to question by Thessaly~</P>

Is a person's animagus form, and patronus form the same animal? Also, I remember in PoA, one of the characters (either Lupin or Black, can't remember which one) said "so and so was USUALLY a so and so." Can't remember which person they were talking about, I don't have my copy of the book on hand to look up. Does this mean you could pick the animal form? If you can't pick the animal form, and it is based on your personality, does that mean as your personality changes the animal may be different as well? ~The Greatly Confused Keyca~</P>

Should Hermione be aging faster then the other characters physically? In PoA she used the time-turner countless times. But she only went backwards, not forwards. So, theoreticaly if you go back an hour and stay there, then you are really an hour older then you should be. Right now Hermione should probably be almost a year older based on how many times she used it. Am I correct to think that? ~The Correctly Aged Keyca~</P>

Why is it that you take so bloody long to write a book? Can't we set deadlines again, so that the series is done before my children are born?(and reading them?) ~Locke~</P>

http://www.keycasplace.tk>

"Let's all play a game of hangman! Now who should we hang"? ~Riley

"If you don't finish that crud on your plate, you won't get any crap for desert" ~Dan on the show Roseanne

CPGKeyca = AIM
Keycas Place = AOL



    
This message has been edited by NarcissaMalfoy on Mar 7, 2004 4:15 PM


 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   

(Login NarcissaMalfoy)
Moderators

Re: Re: Re: Getting some real answers (if possible)

No score for this post
March 7 2004, 4:20 PM 

Ok, first of all if we want her to reply to this letter we should try and keep it less confusing. Chris, while your little nicknames for everyone may be funny to you, they're cluttering up the whole thing and it gets really confusing. I don't even know what the Taco thing is - I'm sure anyone reading the letter and has never seen this board wouldn't either. My centaur and giant questions were tongue in cheek and not at all meant for the letter - it would sound dirty and give her reason not to take it seriously.

Also, from her online interview you can see that she's telling her public that she is impressed with the movie and the actors - insulting Radcliffe (No matter how much I enjoy doing it) will likely get the letter tossed in the bin quicker than anything. Whether we like the movie or not, it's making her a fortune and she probably won't admit it's anything less than brilliant. Sorry, I just thought I'd point the stuff out.

 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   

(Login CPGKeyca)

Re: Getting some real answers (if possible)

No score for this post
March 7 2004, 4:29 PM 

It's okay, take out what you want to take out. And I know you were kidding about the questions, but I felt like adding them anyway. Figured maybe out of all the questions I'd add some that are humerus to lighten the mood instead of just badgering her for questions.

As for the nicknames, I don't expect her to know where the heck they came from. That was just for a laugh for me. If you want to take the nicknames out, take them out (But take every nickname out since you didn't like the idea, not just yours because you didn't like it, yeah I noticed that lol.).



http://www.keycasplace.tk

"Let's all play a game of hangman! Now who should we hang"? ~Riley

"If you don't finish that crud on your plate, you won't get any crap for desert" ~Dan on the show Roseanne

CPGKeyca = AIM
Keycas Place = AOL

 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   
Narcissa
(Login NarcissaMalfoy)
Moderators

Re: Re: Getting some real answers (if possible)

No score for this post
March 7 2004, 4:51 PM 

I only took mine out because it's the only one I had any idea what you were really talking about. The others I'm not too sure of - and I'm too tired to be bothered (and as I said, it's hard to edit when people are messaging me every two seconds) So I didn't bother with taking the others out. Later I'll try to edit it again but right now my arms hurt too much to type properly.

 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   
Lee
(Login phlikk)

Re: Re: Re: Getting some real answers (if possible)

No score for this post
March 7 2004, 6:23 PM 

what is on floor one of the ministry of magic. When Arthur Weasley and Harry are going to Harry's hearing they start at floor seven and go the whole way to 2, with explanations of what is one each floor, and then get off. What is on floor one? is it significant at all?

will any of Sirius's distant family members mentioned on the family tapestry come up again?


Is it possible for someone (like Voldemort) to posses or control the body of a person that has had it's soul sucked out. If Voldemort like got inside Harry's body at the end of book 5, wouldn't it be even easier to inhabit someone without a soul. And once they have could this body apparate and dissaparate inside Hogwarts? Because Hermione in her constant rants about Hogwarts a History says nothing living nor dead can apparate inside the hogwarts grounds. But whenever anyone describes a soul sucked person, they say that they are "niether living nor dead, just an empty shell." Then, wouldn't these soul sucked people have the potential to dissaparate and apparate inside hogwarts grounds, because they don't fall into either category. ?
Even if this exact circumstance doesn't come about, will victims of the dementors kiss ever come back into play in books 6 or 7?



bring back 1912

 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   

(Login RicaEleen)

Re: Re: Re: Re: Getting some real answers (if possible)

No score for this post
March 7 2004, 6:31 PM 

I have one!!!

Was the bartender in the Hog's Head Dumbledore's brother?

*Rica

So the question would be how much more black could it be? And the answer is none, none more black.
-Spinal Tap

AIM-Nifty Nerd 207

 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   

(Login CPGKeyca)

Re: Getting some real answers (if possible)

No score for this post
March 8 2004, 3:47 PM 

So you'll send this out on the 17th? That's two weeks from the date you posted.

http://www.keycasplace.tk

"Let's all play a game of hangman! Now who should we hang"? ~Riley

"If you don't finish that crud on your plate, you won't get any crap for desert" ~Dan on the show Roseanne

CPGKeyca = AIM
Keycas Place = AOL

 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   
Locke
(Login Locke21)

Re: Re: Getting some real answers (if possible)

No score for this post
March 8 2004, 4:05 PM 

I got one, I'm not sure if it has been asked, there are too many questions to be skimmed through.

1.)Why did you allow the movie makers to excellerate the relationship between Ron and Hermione in "Chamber of Secrets"?

 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   
Mad Eye
(Login MadEye)

Re: Re: Getting some real answers (if possible

No score for this post
March 8 2004, 9:35 PM 

IMO, First, regardles of the quality of the letter(and I said before, I'm sure she wil do an excellent job), its not likely that Rowlings will actually read the letter.  Second, if she does read the letter she will not tell us something that gives away something important in the next two books.  Third, if she does give the letter some attention, I doubt that she'll want to read lots of questions.  If she spent all day answering such requests, we'd never get the next book.  SO, again, I suggest that the way to get some answers is to cleverly ask several questions and ask for hints rather than flat out answeres and sign as many board members names as you can come up with.

 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   
Sandy
(Login liturgist)
Moderators

Re: Re: Re: Getting some real answers (if possible

No score for this post
March 8 2004, 10:29 PM 

Chris, I'm actually closing the thread (well, I'll ignore the thread) starting on the 20th.  That will give everyone the weekend to get last things in.

Truth?  I will probably cut questions about the movies.  As Narc pointed out, she proclaims to like the movies and there would be nothing gained by questioning her judgement.  So, Locke, you might want to submit a different question.

As for number, yeah, 300 questions will be a problem.  Try to keep them to your most important issues.  Fewer, higher quality questions are more likely to get some sort of favorable response than zillions of varying quality.

I will post a copy of the letter on the board before I actually mail it.  Give me a few days to write it well (and don't bug me about it in the meantime!!! ).  That way, if you feel I have missed something truly critical, we can work that out.

 



~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~


http://www.schnoogle.com/authorLinks/Sandy_Phoenix
http://www.fanfiction.net/read.php?storyid=1461584

 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   
lilmissmalfoy
(Login lilmissmalfoy)

Re: Getting some real answers (if possible)

No score for this post
March 9 2004, 3:03 AM 

okay mine arent great - but if anyone wants to reword them feel free.....

Is there any real chance that James or Lily may still be living?

Does Voldemort have a weakness?



"Now Now Draco... Play nicely"
Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets



 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   

(Login CPGKeyca)

Re: Getting some real answers (if possible)

No score for this post
March 9 2004, 8:12 AM 

Sandy, want me to try and see if I still have that other interview I never ended up sending? Dispite most of the questions being answered in OotP, and in the online chat, I'm sure not every singe question was answered. Kind of give those questions from people a chance since they went threw the trouble of writting them up for the first interview that I never ended up sending (go me, I'm an idiot, yay!).



http://www.keycasplace.tk

"Let's all play a game of hangman! Now who should we hang"? ~Riley

"If you don't finish that crud on your plate, you won't get any crap for desert" ~Dan on the show Roseanne

CPGKeyca = AIM
Keycas Place = AOL

 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   
Sandy
(Login liturgist)
Moderators

Re: Re: Getting some real answers (if possible)

No score for this post
March 9 2004, 10:18 AM 

Yeah, if you have it, Chris, email it to me.

 

 



~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~


http://www.schnoogle.com/authorLinks/Sandy_Phoenix
http://www.fanfiction.net/read.php?storyid=1461584

 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   

(Login phlikk)

Re: Re: Re: Getting some real answers (if possible)

No score for this post
March 9 2004, 2:53 PM 

voldemort's weakness is his belief that theree is nothing worse than deathy, Dumbledore said that at the end of book 5.

one of my questions was kind of long, so if you want to condense it, feel free

bring back 1912

 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   

(Login CPGKeyca)

Re: Getting some real answers (if possible)

No score for this post
March 10 2004, 10:17 AM 

Well, I can't seem to find it on my computer. But I know I posted the finished copy somewere around here. Maybe I'll go hunting for it if I find time.

http://www.keycasplace.tk

"Let's all play a game of hangman! Now who should we hang"? ~Riley

"If you don't finish that crud on your plate, you won't get any crap for desert" ~Dan on the show Roseanne

CPGKeyca = AIM
Keycas Place = AOL

 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   

(Login CPGKeyca)

New question...YAY!

No score for this post
March 10 2004, 8:41 PM 

What are your laws in the wizerding world regarding wizerds and witches who wish to opperate a muggle moter vehicle (some examples are automobiles, air planes, trains, & boats but are not limited to those vehicles)? We know from when Mr. Wheesly got them for the transportation to Hogwarts that the Ministry has automobiles. We also know that Sirius had the motercycle that could fly, and that Mr. Wheesly had the flying car that could turn invisible. I realize to put charms on them the way that was done is probably breaking some law or another, but to own an operate a normal muggle vehicle, what would be the neccevery steps in doing it legally? And to add onto that question, what are the penalties for breaking such laws by adding charms and being found out? Also, say a wizerd is pulled over by a muggle officer of the law, are they subject to Muggle laws on moving violations, or are they voided out and punished within their own Ministry's law system? And to end this question, I would like to ask if we would ever see some form of this humerous outcome (probably not humerous for the character obviously, but I can't see that not being written in a funny way for the reader)? ~From Keyca, MadEye, Dad-Eye, Narcissa, Riley, & Samantha~



http://www.keycasplace.tk

"Let's all play a game of hangman! Now who should we hang"? ~Riley

"If you don't finish that crud on your plate, you won't get any crap for desert" ~Dan on the show Roseanne

CPGKeyca = AIM
Keycas Place = AOL

 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   
Sev
(Login Severus7800)

Re: Getting some real answers (if possible)

No score for this post
March 13 2004, 11:21 AM 

Ahh...it is a quiet day on the board so far!!

I thought of a couple more questions for Ms. Rowling.

1. Will we ever get to read the letter DD wrote to Aunt
Petunia and left on the doorstep with baby Harry?
2. How do Dobby and Winky know each other before they
come to work at Hogwart's?

 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   
LiLLilac
(Login LiLLilac)

Question

No score for this post
March 13 2004, 3:48 PM 

My question is....

Is there any little bit of vampire in snape? Or am I just picking up these little hints that don't really mean anything?

 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   
LiLLilac
(Login LiLLilac)

Re: Question

No score for this post
March 13 2004, 3:53 PM 

I also had a question that I'm not sure how to ask or word. Feel free to edit. I want to know what role Neville's uncle, who sent him the plant, plays in all of this. And does the plant mean anything? I shis uncle a death eater or against voldemort and will neville, his uncle and this mysterious plant come into books 6 or 7?

 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   

(Login CPGKeyca)

Re: Getting some real answers (if possible)

No score for this post
March 13 2004, 4:32 PM 

You know, Sev, I've always wondered about that letter. I don't know why I didn't think of that. I like it!

And for the last person who posted (Oops, didn't look at the name), that's something I should have added to my question. Wish I thought to ask if he is part vampire if not all in it. Good idea to add that!



http://www.keycasplace.tk

"Let's all play a game of hangman! Now who should we hang"? ~Riley

"If you don't finish that crud on your plate, you won't get any crap for desert" ~Dan on the show Roseanne

CPGKeyca = AIM
Keycas Place = AOL

 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   

(Login Pinchy__5000)

Re: Re: Getting some real answers (if possible)

No score for this post
March 14 2004, 11:28 AM 

Do you regret introducing the concept of Time Turners into the book since it opened up so many potential tricky questions?

--------------------------------------------
In the land of the braindead
The man with one neuron is king
--------------------------------------------

 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   
SoP
(Login SonOfProngs)

Re: Re: Re: Getting some real answers (if possible)

No score for this post
March 14 2004, 1:04 PM 

I have one that I remembered we discussed a few months ago . . .

What is the nature of the position of Minister of Magic and how does one come to act in such a position. Some have proposed that the Minister is elected in the same means that any leader in a Democratic Republic or Parlimentary System. However others, myself included,thought that the Minister was more of a cabinet position apointed by the prime minister of the particular country (mostly because of the few references to consulting or informing the Prime Minister.) Or is it possibly a combination of the two?

you can tweak the wording a bit if you like

The difference between genius and stupidity is that genius has limits

"Remember the enemy's gate is down"- Ender's Game
SoP

 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   
Tymon
(Login LinkShirt)

Re: Re: Re: Re: Getting some real answers (if possible)

No score for this post
March 17 2004, 4:03 PM 

A question I want answered is this:
WHat is the full extent of Ddore's power? In SS, it seems as if he is able to control the weather. When Hagrid goes to the hut-on-the-rock to pick up Harry, he writes Dumbly a letter, saying something to this effect: "I've got Harry, and am taking him to get his things tommorow. WEATHER'S HORRIBLE. Hope your well, from Hagrid." The next day, the hurricane is gone, and it's a perfect day.
Maybe Dumbly decided to help out with the quality of their travel.
Also, what does Lupin do to support himself? He hasn't been teaching forever; just one year. Is there some type of wizard-brand Wellfare program that he's on?
And finally, why the hell is Hermione afraid to say Voldy's name? She was muggle-born as well!

"Sometimes I wonder if I should just move out to a cattle ranch in Montana and watch buffalo mosey by."
~Tom DeLonge of Blink 182
******
Once upon a time there was a little boy who sinned and then he died and went to hell.
I feel bad for his mother....

 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   
Sandy
(Login liturgist)
Moderators

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Getting some real answers (if possible)

No score for this post
March 19 2004, 1:59 PM 

As a note, you all have until tomorrow evening to post your questions.  I don't think this is a problem as pretty much everyone already has.

 

As soon as I have a letter ready, I'll post it.



~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~


http://www.schnoogle.com/authorLinks/Sandy_Phoenix
http://www.fanfiction.net/read.php?storyid=1461584

 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   
Tymon
(Login LinkShirt)

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Getting some real answers (if possible)

No score for this post
March 19 2004, 7:03 PM 

sweeeet.

"We're working on a new type of dance called the Penetrato. It's so promiscuos and lustfull, it makes sex look like a church!"
~The Simpsons, visiting a Brazilian dance school

 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   

(Login CPGKeyca)

Re: Getting some real answers (if possible)

No score for this post
March 19 2004, 9:42 PM 

Hey, Sandy, did you hear from MadEye off the board? I told her she should write up some questions reguarding her board polls that she puts up (can't remember what she called them). I told her that she should turn them into a question of what will happen as apposed to what do you think will happen, and I suggested adding in our statistics of what us, the fans, think. She said she is going away this weekend but would write them out when she got back. I told her I didn't remember when you were sending this out so she should ask you to hold off untill she submits the poll questions. I don't know if she mentioned it or not, so I figured I would incase you were to send it before she does it.

http://www.keycasplace.tk

"Let's all play a game of hangman! Now who should we hang"? ~Riley

"If you don't finish that crud on your plate, you won't get any crap for desert" ~Dan on the show Roseanne

CPGKeyca = AIM
Keycas Place = AOL

 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   
Sandy
(Login liturgist)
Moderators

Re: Re: Getting some real answers (if possible)

No score for this post
March 19 2004, 11:00 PM 

Okay.  I'll wait to hear from her, but I will start writing the letter.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~


http://www.schnoogle.com/authorLinks/Sandy_Phoenix
http://www.fanfiction.net/read.php?storyid=1461584

 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   
Narcissa
(Login NarcissaMalfoy)
Moderators

Re: Re: Re: Getting some real answers (if possible)

No score for this post
March 20 2004, 5:36 PM 

I have one more question. It's not one I think is even debatable but I want to be able to put the annoying theory to rest.

A lot of people seem to think (regardless of the obvious dislike of mudbloods he carried in his youth) that Snape was either in love with or related to Lily. I figure seeing as he called her a mudblood - whish to me seems like their equivelent to a racist slur that he probably hated her as much as the Maurauders. Was he in love with her? Was he her secret brother Perseus Evans? :P

 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   

(Login Lightning-Scar)

Re: Re: Re: Re: Getting some real answers (if possible)

No score for this post
March 20 2004, 7:05 PM 

Even if Voldemort were to reach his goal of imortality, could he still be soul sucked? Further more, could he be soul sucked right now, despite the prophesy, since he wouldn't actually be dead if that happens?

Feel free to re-word that if you want when the message gets sent to JKR.

 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   

(Login CPGKeyca)

Re: Getting some real answers (if possible)

No score for this post
March 21 2004, 3:39 AM 

In addition to the very last question, can you also make that question ask how many outcomes their are that are worse then death and to describe them? Word it however you want. I'm too tired to bother myself lol.

Oh, and that other thread that was brought back from the dead about the copywritten HP titles, ask if they were copywritten to be used or to throw us off, and ask whish titles may be used in the future. Again to tired to really word that good.



http://www.keycasplace.tk

"Let's all play a game of hangman! Now who should we hang"? ~Riley

"If you don't finish that crud on your plate, you won't get any crap for desert" ~Dan on the show Roseanne

CPGKeyca = AIM
Keycas Place = AOL

 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   

(Login MiriamG)

Re: Re: Getting some real answers (if possible)

No score for this post
March 21 2004, 12:34 PM 

Can I still add a couple of questions?

1. Is the prophecy something that influences the future (so that no one CAN kill Harry but Voldey himself) or does it just predict what is going to happen (someone else COULD kill Harry but it's not going to happen)?

2. There is this really annoying theory that Lupin is in fact James and they did some kind of body switch charm before James (or Remus, in that case) was killed. Pleeeeaaaase tell us that this theory is absolute nonsense because it's been really annoying me!!!

-------------------------------------------------------------

Miriam G.

The Mighty and Evil Dark Lord Miriam G. with a Big G. of the Something-Empire

The Queen of the Upas

(picture of a sheep)
by MagicalObizuth

 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   

(Login CPGKeyca)

Re: Getting some real answers (if possible)

No score for this post
March 21 2004, 3:52 PM 

Oh, and what Mirium said gave me an idea. Can you add to her prohpecy question something worded along the lines of "Also, is a prophecy 100% accurate, or is it only a prediction of the most probable outcome in a series of events that may or maynot actually happen, regardless of what is more probbable or not?" If that sounded stupid or didn't make sense then feel free to make it make sense lol!!!

http://www.keycasplace.tk

"Let's all play a game of hangman! Now who should we hang"? ~Riley

"If you don't finish that crud on your plate, you won't get any crap for desert" ~Dan on the show Roseanne

CPGKeyca = AIM
Keycas Place = AOL

 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   
Sandy
(Login liturgist)
Moderators

Re: Re: Getting some real answers (if possible)

No score for this post
March 21 2004, 10:39 PM 

YIKES!  Lots of questions to sort through!

 

Okay, this thread is closed now.  I will start working on a letter and I will post the finished product before I send it.

 

 



~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~


http://www.schnoogle.com/authorLinks/Sandy_Phoenix
http://www.fanfiction.net/read.php?storyid=1461584

 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   

(Login CPGKeyca)

Re: Getting some real answers (if possible)

No score for this post
March 22 2004, 11:25 AM 

Were you going to wait on MadEye, or just send it as is?

http://www.keycasplace.tk

"Let's all play a game of hangman! Now who should we hang"? ~Riley

"If you don't finish that crud on your plate, you won't get any crap for desert" ~Dan on the show Roseanne

CPGKeyca = AIM
Keycas Place = AOL

 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   

(Login CPGKeyca)

Re: Getting some real answers (if possible)

No score for this post
March 25 2004, 1:54 AM 

Just being impatient and wondeirng if you made up the letter yet and if it's ready to post?

(You can yell at me if you want since you did say you'll post it when it's ready. I'm just hyper and impatient if that counts for anything, which it probably doesn't lol!)



http://www.keycasplace.tk

"Let's all play a game of hangman! Now who should we hang"? ~Riley

"If you don't finish that crud on your plate, you won't get any crap for desert" ~Dan on the show Roseanne
"I don't boss Dan around. I'm trying to put him in touch with his submissive side" ~Roseanne

CPGKeyca = AIM
Keycas Place = AOL

 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   
Current Topic - Getting some real answers (if possible)
  << Previous Topic | Next Topic >>  
Create your own forum at Network54
 Copyright © 1999-2009 Network54. All rights reserved.   Terms of Use   Privacy Statement