I no Harry n Ron have suspicsions about him n i concur.

Has Snape definatley changed?

Why does Lucius Malfoy continually praise him to Draco n Umbridge? He is a Death Eater and knows Snape to be the one who left Voldermort's circle and will be killed.

Just wondering...

This has been discussed a LOT on this forum. I think Snape's really a good guy but he's still mean. The good thing about having Snape in the Order is nobody trusts him (except Dumbledore). I'm guessing Snape told Voldemort he's spying on Dumbledore and told DD vice versa. Would Voldemort doubt Snape's loyalty? Voldemort must like him a lot because they both hate Harry. Also Snape looks like a bad guy, and acts like a bad guy. He looks eviler than most Death Eaters even. But if Voldemort trusts Snape this much he must have been a very evil Death Eater at some point.

Perhaps butim not completley convinced. Am I right in saying that Voldermort looks upon his circle and in one gap says 'one has left me forever, he will be killed' Snape? but does he also say 'this is where my loyalest subject would stand. He will be rewarded'. Is this Crouch jr. Or SNAPE?

That night when they found Barty Crouch Jr, Snape showed Dumbledore the dark mark on his arm getting stronger, and Dumbledore said something along the lines of "Well you know what I need you to do" and Snape left immediately so he most likely went to see Voldemort- Although I do think that it was Snape that Voldemort was referring to when he said "one I believe has left me forever"

I dont know about anyone else but the fact that you kept writing "n" instead of "and" really bugs the s*** out of me. Especially since it only seems to be laziness as you managed to type out the whole word out at the end of your thread! Please dont abbreviate too much as people will just end up not reading your threads.

Now that I've got that out of the way - this has indeed been discussed to death. This was one of the more ambiguous parts in the book that could have been interpreted in a number of ways, depending on the reader. There was the choice of Snape or Karkaroff, but the 'Loyal' one was Barty Crouch Jnr, and that was well evident in the book.


"Now Now Draco... Play nicely"
Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets