<< Previous Topic | Next Topic >>  

A Poll About POA

June 9 2004 at 10:53 PM
No score for this post		MadEye  (Login MadEye)
 
Mugglenet.com has a poll running about whether you liked the movie or not.  You may want to nip over there and give your opinion.  
I also thought we could do our own poll about the movie.  Not just “I hated it” but a bit more in depth.  Play along if you like, I’ll post the results in the end. Sorry for the way it looks, Excel kept screwing it up.  But you get the idea. 
There are 2 sections, In the first give a rating from 1 –10.   In the second, give each item a Yes or No in each of the three listed categories. (– was it true to the book / did it make sense and was it easy to follow / was it entertaining) (Sorry, there are about 50 items)
On a scale of 1 – 10 (where 10 is “I loved it” and 1 is “I hated it”)
  1.                  Rate the movie – overall
  2.                  Rate the acting of Gary Oldman (Sirius Black)  
  3.                  Rate the acting of David Twelis (Remus Lupin)
  4.                  Rate the acting of Daniel Radcliffe (Harry Potter)
  5.                  Rate the acting of Emma Watson (Hermione Granger)
  6.                  Rate the Acting of Gambon (Dumbledore)
  7.                  Rate the Acting of Alan Rickman(Severus Snape)
  8.                  Rate the acting of Rupert Grint(Ron Weasley)
  9.                  Rate the acting of Tom Fenton(Draco Malfoy)
  10.              Rate the acting of (Sybil Trelawney)
  11.              Rate the script
  12.              Rate the special effects- Buckbeak
  13.                               Whomping Willow
  14.                              Snuffles (Sirius the dog)
  15.                               Werewolf 
  16.                               Harry’s Patronus
  17.                              Dementors
  18.                               Blowing up Aunt Marge
  19.                               Knight Bus
  20.                               Monster Book of Monsters
  21.                               Mauraders Map
  22.              Rate the look of the film - Hogwarts castle
  23.                               Hagrid’s House
  24.                               Flying scene with Buckbeak
  25.                  Rate the sound track
  26.                  Rate the costumes
True to the book (Y/N) Made Sense(Y/N) Enter-taining (Y/N)                  

 

      1. The Aunt Marge Scene(w/ the Dursley’s and Marge)
      2.  Knight Bus Scene(w/ Stan, the head, Ernie)
      3.  The Leaky Cauldron scene (W/Tom, Fudge, The book, Arthur   Weasley)
      4.    The Train scene (w/Ron, Hermione, Lupin)
      5.  The Great Hall scene(w/ the chorus, Dumbledore,Hagrid)
      6.  The Hippogriff scene(w/Hagrid, Beaky, Draco)
      7. The Boggart scene (w/Lupin, Neville, Ron, Snape boggart)
      8.   The Qudditch Match(w/dementors, Dumbledore)
      9.  The dark hallway scene(w/Snape, the map, Lupin)
      10.   The bad news for Beaky scene(w/Hermione, Hagrid, Ron)
      11.  The Snape takes Lupins class scene (w, Hermione, Draco, Snape, Ron)
      12 .  The visit to Hagrids and Hermione hits Draco scene (w/ Hagrid, Hermione, Ron, Draco)
      13.  Divination Class, including the grim tea reading and the prophesy, 2 scenes (w/ Trelwaney, Ron, Hermione)
      14.   The Hogsmeade scene including Harry getting the map(w/ Fred, George, Ron, Hermione, Rosemerta, McGonagall, Fudge)
      15.  Patronus Lesson scene (w/ Lupin, dementor-boggart)
      16.   Lupin and Harry talks – at least 2 scenes(w/Lupin)
      17.   Whomping Willow scene (w/ Snuffles, Ron, Hermione)
      18.  Shreiking Shack scene( w/ Ron, Hermione, Sirius, Lupin, Peter, Snape)
      19.  Full moon/ werewolf scene (w, the same)
      20.   Time turner scenes (all of the above)
      21.   Ending scenes –Sirius escapes/Lupin gives back the map/Harry gets the broom
Yes No   Will you see the movie more than once - in the theatre

 

 


 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   
AuthorReply

(Login Koolio2)

Re: A Poll About POA

No score for this post		June 10 2004, 12:11 AM 

Please note that most of these were because I didn't like the way the movie portrayed them(Alan,Gary,David). And also Dan's would have been a 10 without the crying sequence, that was awful.

1. 5 Rate the movie – overall
2. 4 Rate the acting of Gary Oldman (Sirius Black)
3. 2 Rate the acting of David Twelis (Remus Lupin)
4. 9 Rate the acting of Daniel Radcliffe (Harry Potter)

5. 10 Rate the acting of Emma Watson (Hermione Granger)
6. 8 Rate the Acting of Gambon (Dumbledore)
7. 1 Rate the Acting of Alan Rickman(Severus Snape)
8. 10 Rate the acting of Rupert Grint(Ron Weasley)
9. 11 Rate the acting of Tom Fenton(Draco Malfoy)
10. 7 Rate the acting of (Sybil Trelawney)
11. 3 Rate the script
12. 10 Rate the special effects- Buckbeak
13. 10 Whomping Willow
14. 1 Snuffles (Sirius the dog)
15. 7 Werewolf
16. 1 Harry’s Patronus
17. 7 Dementors
18. 10 Blowing up Aunt Marge
19. 10 Knight Bus
20. 9 Monster Book of Monsters
21. 2 Mauraders Map
22. 3 Rate the look of the film - Hogwarts castle
23. 8 Hagrid’s House
24. 6 Flying scene with Buckbeak
25. 8? Rate the sound track
26. 6/7 Rate the costumes


True to the book (Y/N) Made Sense(Y/N) Enter-taining (Y/N)


Y/N/Y 1. The Aunt Marge Scene(w/ the Dursley’s and Marge)
N/N/Y 2. Knight Bus Scene(w/ Stan, the head, Ernie)
N/N/Y? 3. The Leaky Cauldron scene (W/Tom, Fudge, The book, Arthur Weasley)
Y/N/N 4. The Train scene (w/Ron, Hermione, Lupin)
N/N/Y! 5. The Great Hall scene(w/ the chorus, Dumbledore,Hagrid)
Y?/Y/Y 6. The Hippogriff scene(w/Hagrid, Beaky, Draco)
N/Y/N 7. The Boggart scene (w/Lupin, Neville, Ron, Snape boggart)
Y/Y/Y 8. The Qudditch Match(w/dementors, Dumbledore)
N/N/N 9. The dark hallway scene(w/Snape, the map, Lupin)
N/Y/Y 10. The bad news for Beaky scene(w/Hermione, Hagrid, Ron)
N/N/Y 11. The Snape takes Lupins class scene (w, Hermione, Draco, Snape, Ron)
N/Y/Y 12 . The visit to Hagrids and Hermione hits Draco scene (w/ Hagrid, Hermione, Ron, Draco)
N/N/Y 13. Divination Class, including the grim tea reading and the prophesy, 2 scenes (w/ Trelwaney, Ron, Hermione)
N/N/Y 14. The Hogsmeade scene including Harry getting the map(w/ Fred, George, Ron, Hermione, Rosemerta, McGonagall, Fudge)
N/Y/N 15. Patronus Lesson scene (w/ Lupin, dementor-boggart)
N/N/Y 16. Lupin and Harry talks – at least 2 scenes(w/Lupin)
Y/Y/Y 17. Whomping Willow scene (w/ Snuffles, Ron, Hermione)
N/N/N 18. Shreiking Shack scene( w/ Ron, Hermione, Sirius, Lupin, Peter, Snape)
N/Y/N 19. Full moon/ werewolf scene (w, the same)
N/Y/Y 20. Time turner scenes (all of the above)
N/Y?/Y 21. Ending scenes –Sirius escapes/Lupin gives back the map/Harry gets the broom


Yes No Will you see the movie more than once - in the theatre

I already have. It was much better the 2nd time becuase I knew what not to expect.


~GwP~

 
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.Respond to this message   
Current Topic - A Poll About POA
  << Previous Topic | Next Topic >>  
Create your own forum at Network54
 Copyright © 1999-2009 Network54. All rights reserved.   Terms of Use   Privacy Statement