Ok so we know that both Sirius and Dumbledore are supposed to be dead, right? My opinion (I probably just think this because I love sirius) is that sirius is not dead. I mean they never found his body right? I really do think Dumbledore is dead as much as I don't want that to be the case.

Well They reason they didn't find his body is b/c if they went back there they would die jus like SIRIUS DID.



Working on gettin' ALL SEVEN!!

do we really have proof that he died???

Ummm...so yeah, Sirius was definitely my FAVORITE character. I was really disappointed when he died...but I don't think he'll come back. His will took effect: Kreacher now belongs to Harry, and you can tell because he obeys Harry. If Sirius's will has taken effect, then Sirius must be dead.

i think dumbeldor is still alive only because of the pheonix harry though he saw during is funeral, it could meen that or that his pheonix died with him. Guess it depends on how you look at it. But you never know since he could hear voices from where serious died maybe they can hear him to if he were to try and communicate.