<< Previous Topic | Next Topic >>Return to Index  

JGSDF Type 90

March 11 2003 at 12:35 AM
No score for this post
  (no login)
from IP address 200.42.81.117

 
Recently I have bought a kit of Trumpeter's JGSDF Type 90 (ref. MM008).
Is a good kit?
Are the moulds from Tamiya?
What things must be improved?
Where I can obtain information (close ups) on this tank?

TIA

Pato

 
Scoring_Disabled_MsgRespond to this message   
AuthorReply

(no login)
208.170.232.133

it is a bad kit

No score for this post
March 11 2003, 10:58 AM 

The Type 90 from Trumpeter is a bad, bad copy of hte Tamiya kit. It was badly pantographed, is underscale, more like 1/42 and was not molded well. Sorry to say it is more a toy than a model.

 
Scoring_Disabled_MsgRespond to this message   

(no login)
200.42.95.183

Oh my God...!!! n/t

No score for this post
March 12 2003, 12:02 AM 

.

 
Scoring_Disabled_MsgRespond to this message   

(Login Patopato)
200.42.81.125

But, Jacques...

No score for this post
March 12 2003, 5:23 AM 

...I have measured the superestructure of the kit. The real vehicle measures 3.4 meters wide, and the scale model measures 97mm.
This is almost exactly 1/35.

It seems that the total length (barrel included) is slightly inferior to the scale model of Tamiya (278mm Tamiya vs. 270 Trumpeter).

I'm very confused.
Why you say that the scale is 1/42?

Cheers
Pato

 
Scoring_Disabled_MsgRespond to this message   

(Login Jacques1001)
208.170.232.21

my answer

No score for this post
March 12 2003, 11:34 PM 

I am going by what the Trumpeter kit looked like next to the Tamiya kit...I do not have dimensions for the Type-90, and did not look them up in the internet. I only noticed that while the trumpeter kit looked like a tamiya copy, it also looked smaller. If your measurements are correct, then it appears it was a optical illusion to me.

The two kits that came out in this release from trumpeter, the Type 90 and the LeClerc, have gotten a lot of bad press, and look to have deserved it when I eyeballed the kits thinking of buying them.

Also, the BMP-1 copy that Trumpeter did IS as awful as has been described, especially in the running gear. And the T-72 with mineroller is a buldable copy of the Tamiya kit, but the turret is just horrible, as is the figure.

Trumpeter used to be pretty much a motorized model company, and would copy other companies kits and add motorization to them. THey also made their own kits to be motorized, the T-55 series in particular. But starting with, I believe the M1A1 series of kits, Trumpeter is becoming more of a serious model company.

 
Scoring_Disabled_MsgRespond to this message   

(no login)
200.42.95.183

Measures

No score for this post
March 13 2003, 10:20 AM 

Ok Jacques, sincerely the Type 90 does not seem to be so bad kit. The main measures are almost the same ones that kit of Tamiya, although the details seem to be less accurate and "soft".
The running train is quite bad (the kit is motorized).
Perhaps when I build it I can write a small rewiew.

Thanks for your aid, always it is good to listen other opinions.

Cheers

Pato

 
Scoring_Disabled_MsgRespond to this message   
Current Topic - JGSDF Type 90
  << Previous Topic | Next Topic >>Return to Index  
Create your own forum at Network54
 Copyright © 1999-2009 Network54. All rights reserved.   Terms of Use   Privacy Statement