HELLO KARS, YOU SAID YOU ARE WILLING TO TALK ABOUT OLD COMMUNITIES. WE ARE ARMENIAN MALAKANS AND MY GRANDPARENTS LIVED IN KARAKALA. THERE ARE THREE KARAKALA VILLAGES IN THE KARS REGION. I ALWAYS THOUGHT OUR KARAKALA WAS NORTH OF KARS IN THE AREA OF VORONTSOVKA, DUBOVKA, CHAKMAK. MY GREAT GRANDFATHER LIVED IN ALL THOSE VILLAGES INCLUDING KARAKALA WHERE MOST OF MY FAMILY CAME FROM. DO YOU KNOW WHICH KARAKALA WAS THE VILLAGE OF THE ARMENIAN PROTESTANTS/MALAKANS? IS IT THE ONE SOUTH OF KARS, OR THE KARAKALA MORE SOUTH EAST OF KARS? OR THE ONE NORTH OF KARS. I WILL APPRECIATE YOUR HELP.
