You did state "posters" . . that is still such few people. My position remains that it is too few to be taken as representative of all who enter this site and might find it useful. Its like saying that only those who write letters to the editor or call a radio talk program should have a say in our national decisions. I don't think you are meaning to say that, are you?
The debate is probably meaningless anyway. Nat owns the site, so if he alone wanted to ban someone, he can. Others' opinions on the matter don't carry any weight unless he chooses to consider them.