Bartman wasn't THAT bad last year, was he? After all, dependable defensive defensemen are hard to come by in the WHL. I would say Barts could be a good third OA. I wouldn't want him as a captain or anything, but he rounds out a good defense corps for us.
Spurgeon - if he returns - is a lock. After that, Donaghy is O.K....but I don't like the idea of keeping Bartman AND Donaghy. I would rather see us replace either one of them for a more proven player.
I, also, don't see any of the Collegiate guys coming over. Isn't Jake Hansen a Columbus Blue Jackets prospect? If anything, he will go the AHL route. Good luck getting Nycholat to come here.