The QBasic Forum      Other Subforums, Links and Downloads
 

in theory, it's not good or bad

by mennonite (no login)


in practice, it's a complete mess. they could turn it into something that isn't, but instead it's pretty much become an excuse to do it the most freebasic-defeating way possible... to make it into a language that is not actually basic, not actually c. just a muddled, useless pile of crap, mistakenly called "beta" when in fact they're CLEARLY still in the "alpha" stage, and can't even work that out with any kind of proper design.

in other words, the way they're doing it is a way to skip designing the language at all. that's fine for the hardcore fans, fine for the people that want to put up with the mess for some reason, bad for anyone that would be serious about it as a language, want to write good documentation, (the freebasic documentation is already a jumbled mess full of factual errors about qb that are easy to find, and about the freebasic language that are nearly impossible to find and fix) or try to get other people to use it.

it's not a language, it's a cult with its own sort of made up "lingo" the same way the stuff that scientologists talk about isn't a real "language." nor a real dialect. it's just sort of built up like the tower in a jenga game.

you think something like that has a future? okay, let's see. i guarantee it won't so long as it sticks proudly to the non-plan it is based on. even i, in my casual, low-organization mode of hobby coding would take more care when designing a language. you have to know better than that.

Posted on Feb 6, 2007, 3:59 PM

Respond to this message   

Return to Index


Response TitleAuthor and Date
I think it is simply misunderstood.rpgfan3233 on Feb 6
 except that it's not free as in beer, as much as it's free as in basingmennonite on Feb 6
  i can say it better than that of coursemennonite on Feb 7
   sj zero said it better too:mennonite on Feb 7
   I don't want to make a promise I can't keep, but... on Feb 13
    that will certainly help...mennonite on Feb 13
Well,here's a comparison. on Feb 7
 Think about it this way...rpgfan3233 on Feb 7
  "The only reason I like FB is because I can (basically) write C programs in a simpler..."mennonite on Feb 7
   *i forgot: "go-eat-a-treebasic"mennonite on Feb 14
  Well,the problem lies with IO and Windows mostly. on Feb 21
 freebasic to officially abandon attempts at qb compatibility by version 1.0mennonite on Feb 7
  FB has C behavior. The -lang switch is there to allow for QB behavior to be emulated.rpgfan3233 on Feb 7
   *yes, i know... did you read that it isn't even going to exist in version 1.0?mennonite on Feb 7
    Depending on how much of the "FB community" uses it, that could change.rpgfan3233 on Feb 7
     you're kidding. you'd really have to bemennonite on Feb 8
      Dont you guys ever... on Feb 15
       * Not very possible... People here occasionally migrate to FB, but still enjoy QB.rpgfan3233 on Feb 15
       i'll be tired of the issue when the issue has been resolvedmennonite on Feb 15
        mennonite to English translator: That means: No! he'll never be tired of it.Pete on Feb 15
         LOL on Feb 15

Newbies usually go to www.qbasic.com and click on The QBasic Forum
Forum regulars have their own ways, which include The QBasic Community Forums