February 28 2007 at 10:16 AM No score for this post
-
...Slovianski-P is going to combine the vocabulary common to most Slavic languages with a simple, yet Slavic grammar. This simplicity and pan-Slavic vocabulary should make it unusually easy to learn for a Slav and understandable at first sight to hundreds of millions of people.
As far as phonology and grammar are concerned, Slovianski-P adopts only what is present in all contemporary Slavic languages and therefore understood by all Slavs. In other words, Slovianski-P always uses the simplest solution of all natural Slavic ones...
As far as phonology and grammar are concerned, Slovianski-P adopts only what is present in all contemporary Slavic languages and therefore understood by all Slavs.
Presenting what is " present in all centemporary Slavic languages and therefore
!!! understood by all Slavs !!! is NONSENSE.
Do you know why ?
Lots of words in one slavic language[s] is / are not understood in the others.
I know a lot of words that are in polish, czech, slovak, croatian langs but
not in e.g. ukrainian, rusian or belorussian langs - and vice versa.
Alleging that slovianski-P adopts "only what is present in all contemporary
Slavic langs" AND AT THE SAME TIME " understood by all Slavs cannot be true.
P.S. we had already some debates on this topic some time ago. Do you remember ?
Iopq is right. It isn't possible to find unversal all-Slavic words for every concept. I spoke just about grammar, where it is possible to find a solution that will be easy and natural for all Slavs.
But anyway, even if I spoke about vocabulary, I don't know what you are complaining about. Even if there is a 100% all-Slavic word, such as nauka, it is not sure that your lang will adopt it.
Gabriel pisal:
...As all natural Slavic languages, Slovianski-P is a SEXIST language, i.e. the basic form can express either a male person or a person of unspecified sex (prijatel, prorok), while the exclusively female form is formed by means of the suffix -ica (prijatelica, prorokica). ..
===
Slovar
Test-stol = test-bench(en), Prüfstand(de)
trudilna-stol = workbench(en), stoł warsztatowy(pl)
sekzizm = sexism
seksist = sexist n
seksist-ju = sexist a
Igor:
...It said "phonology and grammar" NOT "vocabulary or lexical terms"
===
Igor ja ne dolzxbi obiasnit tebe, zxe vse jazika Slavju imat svoi UNIKATJU fonologia.
To znacxit zxe podobost slovstvom es vazxnju i ne fonologia.
...As far as phonology and grammar are concerned, Slovianski-P adopts only what is present in all contemporary Slavic languages and therefore understood by all Slavs.
And S - lingva and Slovio adopted only what is present in all contemporary Slavic languages as well.
Do you think, Gabriel, that S-lingva adopted some other phonology or grammar ?
If yes, could you write some examples, please ?
Igor:
Slovio grammar is not Slavic. No Slavic language has Nominative and Accusative cases and none else.
Either use Nominative ONLY or use 6 cases. Choose out of the options available in Natural languages.
===
Bik-govno!
Slovio takak Anglio and Bugario imat subiektivju i obiektivju padesx:
And S - lingva and Slovio adopted only what is present in all contemporary Slavic languages as well.
Do you think, Gabriel, that S-lingva adopted some other phonology or grammar ?
If yes, could you write some examples, please ?
All Slavic languages have three genders, Slovio and S-lingva don't.
All Slavic langauges have variable adjectives, Slovio and S-lingva don't.
All Slavic languages have present tense conjugation, S-lingva doesn't.
Slovio and S-lingva are certainly Slavic-inspired (and I don't definitely say that it is bad), but they are not Slavic.
Gabriel:
(Yeah, my language is even more complicated in this respect, but my langauge claims to be neither simple, nor easy, nor logical. Your language does.)
If you will be able to speak and understand these 3 languages you do not have to know any artificial language like Slovianski - P and most of Slavic nations will understand you.
Anonimnik pisal:
SLOVAK, SERBO-CROATINA, RUSSIAN
If you will be able to speak and understand these 3 languages you do not have to know any artificial language like Slovianski - P and most of Slavic nations will understand you.
===
Zdrav Anonimnik!
Ja Slovio-nik. Imasx pravda Slovianski-P to "good for nothing". Ja ne gvorija i razumja po Slovakju, po Serbo-Kroatju i po Rusju no dumaja zxe ti mne razumit.
Hellerick pisal:
To say the truth, Gabriel, I mostly didn’t like the changes you’ve made. What you got isn’t Slovianski-P anymore; it’s rather Slovianski-N of Bulgarian level. It can’t be described as ‘simple’ now, and I doubt that anybody (including you) is able to learn it.
===
bez komentar
Glavnju problem Slovianskiju troikam (Gabriel-Iopq-Hellerick) jest zxe oni probit kvdratit krug.
Vse-Slavju izgoverenie ne bil nie bu i nigda bilbi.
Slovio-voi vigod nad Slovianski jest zxe Slovio tolk imat 25 bukva/bukva-kombinenie i zxe vsektor cxlovek imat pravda izgvorit ih kak on mozxit; i ne kak GIH-troika prikazit!
