Spring vs Nitro pistonDecember 13 2010 at 4:39 PM
|Joe (Login joebishop)|
from IP address 126.96.36.199
PLEASE START A NEW THREAD. THIS IS REALLY TOO OLD.
THANKS, THE MGMT.
I am new to air rifles and wanting to purchase a new rifle. I have been reading a lot about the new Nitro piston and was wandering if that is the way to go. I almost had myself talked into buying a RWS 34 with the new T06 trigger, but was wandering if I should go the Nitro piston route instead. Any help would be appreciated.
|This message has been edited by RedFeather from IP address 188.8.131.52 on Sep 16, 2013 10:54 AM|
|December 13 2010, 4:46 PM |
is like going into a Mercedes Benz dealer and asking what brand of car to buy. LOL
Havent tried a rammed gun yet but i love my .20 cal 34 and .22 cal 38.
|December 13 2010, 5:06 PM |
|December 13 2010, 5:09 PM |
What are you loooking for in an air rifle.
The 34 will give you all of this. And your children as well when you are done with it.
The Nitro. Some of the above, but not all. And you will probably be buying your children something else.
Like a 34.
There is a good solid reason why the Diana 34 is considered THE entry level airgun.
Try this, if you can, cock and hold a 34. Do the same with a Nitro. Look them over good. Fit and finish, balance, FEEL.
The answer will bew right there in your hands.
Oh, one more thing. If for any reason you are dissatisfied with either gun, try selling the Nirto and see what you can get.
You will have no trouble finding a home for the 34.
I would try the 34 first
|December 13 2010, 5:25 PM |
Nitros seem to be good (assume you are talking Crosman?) but the 34 is old school at about its best.
I have them both
|December 13 2010, 6:16 PM |
one Crosman made in China Titan GP in .22 cal and ALL M34's in .177, and .22 cal made in Germany
the Titan GP in .22 cal from Wally World is $150.00 plus .07 tax and not a bad air rifle but make that "1 stike" because it is a cheap air rifle, did not say a bad one!!!
the M34 in .177 or .22 cal is a $200.00 AIR RIFLE, see CAPS letters???
better quality, better MOD's avaliable (sorry) you cannot modify the Titan, make that "2 stikes"
resale value is still $200.00 for the Model 34 even if you use it 1 day or 1 year
if the spring in the M34 "EVER", (breaks, cants, or weakens) and goes bad, it is a $20.00 replacement but not the same story for the Titan, "3 stikes"
you are "OUT" with 3 strkes'
the difference between the Titan GP ($150.00) and the Diana M34 ($200.00) is $50.00
do YOU want to gamble!!!, it's your money
and remember "it's 30% the gun and 70% the shooter"
M34 it is
|December 13 2010, 6:32 PM |
Thanks for all the helpful insite. Looks like I will be ordering an M34 in .22 Any advice for which pellets to try. I will mainly be hunting squirrels and birds in my back yard and plinking at some targets and tin cans.
your best bet
|December 13 2010, 6:55 PM |
Would be a pellet sampler. would be best to call straight shooters and see if they have a .22 34, order the sampler with the rifle.
BTW they are offering free shipping through the 20th i believe
|December 13 2010, 7:46 PM |
Realize that how ever the gun shoots out of the box it will not settle in untill you have run at least 1000 pellets through it. Take a breath, that's only 2 tins. And trust me, you will enjoy every one, and will be more and more impressed as you go. With yourself and the gun. Its a win/win situation.
PS Warren forgot to mention that there have been 250,000 34s produced since they were first brought out. 250,000! And there's a good reason for that.
That's not like him. You're welcome, Warren.
You might want to check
|December 14 2010, 5:14 PM |
With whom ever you purchase a M34 that it has the new TO6 trigger.
|December 14 2010, 7:13 PM |
Do not limit yourself to comments here. I personally own a 34 and can attest to the great quality. However, I think there is something to the gas ram. I have two Beeman C1's. I am going to get one with a gas ram installed, and then be able to make a judgment after a true comparison. I would love to see a Diana 34 with a gas ram. Hey! Think out of the BOX!!!
|December 14 2010, 9:09 PM |
Blasphemer! Dr. Frankenstein!
|December 15 2010, 2:35 AM |
the original poster wanted to know which one between a gas ram and a spring power air rifle
and based on that criteria most of us decided on a M34
now saying that we must remember that the first kit Vortek produced was for the M34, then why not??
a gas ram for the M34!!!
HEY!!! Tom Gore, I know you read the forums, just read this one and let us know, eventually someone is going to make them
it's just a matter on TIME
and remember "it's 30% the gun and 70% the shooter"
Got for a TX200 and you'll never look back
|December 15 2010, 2:00 PM |
|December 15 2010, 5:30 PM |
or The special 34 in .20 with a LW Bull barrel, and a used 34 in your choice of cal. Same price JMO
Re: Spring vs Nitro piston
|December 16 2010, 1:48 AM |
Ram vs Spring
|December 24 2010, 11:01 AM |
My Son has a model 34, very nice for the price. Compared to any Crossman I think the choice is obvious. Ram vs spring is something completely different. There is no clear winner over another in medium powered air guns. It really is a matter of preference. Now....when it comes to high powered air rifles like the Crow Mag or the RX2 you really need a ram to achieve this type of power effectively.
Terry in LP
"...need a ram to achieve this type of power effectively."
|December 24 2010, 2:17 PM |
Héctor J Medina G
Purely semantical doubt
|December 25 2010, 11:57 AM |
Of course you are free to use the words any way you want. And to define "effectiveness" any which way you choose.
IMHO effectiveness should be regarded as the ability to get a job done. Which is different from efficiency in the sense that efficiency is the ability to do a particular work with the least amount of resources possible.
Now, taking numbers from a well respected source: Straightshooters, we come to the following data:
RX2) Weight.-9.8 lbs without scope, ME.- 19-20 ft-lbs, Cocking Effort.- Heavy; Recoil Rating.- Heavy; Price.- $819
D54) Weight.-9.0 lbs without scope, ME.- 17-21 ft-lbs; Cocking Effort.- Medium; Recoil Rating.- Heavy; Price.- $555
Notwithstanding the experiences published here that tell us that the D54 is capable of performances better than this, let's just say the I fail to see where the purported "effectiveness" of the GasRammed rifles is.
Care to explain?
Re: Purely semantical doubt
|December 25 2010, 12:06 PM |
Not really. I was not making the statement in terms of painting such a broad brush. Simply saying, bone stock, generally speaking the gas ram power plant are the ones you typically see with the highest fpe number. Granted the difference may be small, and a spring piston could be modded to equal, but that isn't where I was going.