You aked for critiques..
This line says a lot " the pages are graphic heavy."
Your title image takes up nearly a whole screen. People hate to scroll. I hear it's especially annoying on webTV.
If you're redoing the whole site you should take this opportunity to get into compliance with the RUG guidelines for fansites and remove all show logos and lyrics. It's a pain in the rear end--I'm not doing it with my old layout on catsmusical.com, but on the new one no logos to be found and I'm going to put the lyrics in a pass protected area for my own enjoyment (and the enjoyment of anyone who can figure out how to get in.)
The next thing is that you page is extremely hard to navigate. I actually get your site and idio's site mixed up because of this. Youtwo both have similar rectangular links with text and stuff.
It takes me a lot of clicking to be able to tell that the pictures are in "life to..." rather than "Jellicles are" or "Jellicle Cats." Same thing with
"A caper..." or "A Toothful.." and some others. You don't know what's in them till you clikc
While the sept 11th graphic and the "spay or neuter" log are good causes, for the sake up 56k'ers you may want to put them in a section for causes you support.. The large size slows down page loading.
Centering everyting down the middle of a page makes for a nicely balanced site.. but.. everyone and their grandmother's grandmother does it.. It's extremly basic design.