iVarta.com Discussion Forum. at India News, Classifieds, Yellowpages, Business Listing, Yellow Pages or at India News, Classifieds, Yellowpages, Business Listing, Yellow Pages, Online Tickets
 


  << Previous Topic | Next Topic >>Return to Index  

Romila thappar appointment - US backed Marxist Assault on India's History

April 23 2003 at 7:27 AM
Mahendra Joshi 

 
Petition Against US backed Marxist Assault on India's History
http://www.petitiononline.com/108india/petition.html

To: US Library of Congress

It is a great travesty that Romila Thapar has been appointed the first holder of the Kluge Chair in
Countries and Cultures of the South at the Library of
Congress.

In regards to India, she is an avowed antagonist of
India's Hindu civilization. As a well-known Marxist,
she represents a completely Euro-centric world view.
I fail to see how she can be the correct choice to
represent India's ancient history and civilization.
She completely disavows that India ever had a history.

Just as the Europeans discredited the American
Indian's land claims by ignoring that they represented
a unique civilization with a wholesome variety of
distinct linguistic and cultural traits, Thapar has
long expounded the same ignorant view of India's
unique history and civilization.

The ongoing campaign by Romila Thapar and others to
discredit Hindu civilization is a war of cultural
genocide. By your unfortunate selection of R.Thapar
for the Kluge Chair in Countries and Cultures of the
South at the Library of Congress, America is now aiding and
abbeting this effort.

The result of her "Historical Consciousness in Early
India" is already a foregone conclusion. She will of
course attempt to show that Early India had no
historical consciousness.

Why waste our American resources on a
Marxist idealogical assault on Hindu
civilization?Hinduism is the world's most ancient,
ongoing and largest cultural phenonmenon. Such a long
lived civilization surely has alot to teach the world.
So why support its denigration? As a Friend of India, I protest this appointment.



 
 Respond to this message   
AuthorReply
Shashi from Bengal

Unsuccessful mission

April 25 2003, 10:53 AM 

It looks the whole world is consciously or unconsciously wants to work against Hindusim. And that itself proves that the hostile world wants to use human being to stop the ressurgence of Sanatan Dharma.

But I personally believe that these human efforts will not succeed against God's will. And that is true in all spheres of life. Those who elected Romila will lament later.

All the previous European attempt to bash Indian culture and its religion did not succeed.

 
 
Dahyabhai

How Romila Thapar and her fellow communists attack India's Cultural Heritage

April 25 2003, 5:51 PM 

Here we shall simply specify some prime targets of Communism in its battle against Ancient Indian heritage and culture.
http://www.bharatvani.org/books/hsus/ch5.htm
They are as follows:
1. The first and foremost target of Communism is Sanătana Dharma enshrined in Hindu literature and made living by a long line of saints, mystics and bhaktas. Communism ridicules all this wealth of unrivalled spiritual splendour.......

2. Next, Communism makes an aggressive move towards ancient Dharmashăstras which have their source in Sanătana Dharma and which lay down the moral and social principles by which a wholesome social and individual life is sustained. Communism denounces these Dharmashăstras as respositories of primitive prescriptions.........

3. Thirdly, Communism concentrates on Hindu philosophies which expound, compare, contrast, fortify and defend the manifold metaphysical points of view flowing into several streams from the self-same Sanătana Dharma. It condemns all these philosophies as Brahminical conspiracies ....Rahul Sankrityayana was a great pedlar of this Communist lore among the Hindi reading public. .... He postulated that the Buddha was preaching Marxism for all practical purposes .....

4. Fourthly-and here Communism has really invested some herculean endeavours-it ransacks the annals of Hindu history and Hindu heroism. A whole battalion of Communist historians have been busy for years battering the walls of Hindu historiography .....They have ridiculed every hero, every period, every episode, and every precedent in which Hindus can take pride. The Golden Age of the Imperial Guptas in which Hindu achievements attained their acme in the fields of art, literature and science is dismissed as a myth by D.N. Jha whose Ancient India: ...Other Communist historians have portrayed Maharana Pratap, Shivaji and Guru Govind Singh as local rebels against pax moslemanica for petty personal ends. The same historians whitewash bloodthirsty Islamic conquerors and despicable despots.....
5. Lastly, the Communist anthropologists and sociologists dive deep into Hindu social institutions, customs, mores and manners and come up with some class interest hiding inside the core in each case. We are told that Hindu society has always been an unhealthy society except perhaps during the Vedic period when, according to ROMILA THAPAR, our Aryan ancestors ate beef. Beef-eating by the ancient Aryans has been such an obsession with Miss Thapar that she returns to the theme again and again, even when discussing the dancing girl found in the ruins of Mohenjo-daro.

How hostile Communism can be to everything Hindu is proved by an incident in which S.A. Dange and his son-in-law, Deshpande, got involved a few years ago. Deshpande wrote quite a scholarly book in which he propounded that several important principles of modern mathematics and science (including dialectical materialism which is the greatest principle of modern science according to Communism) were first discovered by systems of Hindu philosophy, notably SăMkhya and Vedănta. .....Where Deshpande went wrong was that he took a genuine pride in the ancient Hindu past and expressed it in no mean measure. Dange himself contributed a Preface ...... Little did they know the consequences of what they had done. The Party came down upon them like a ton of bricks. It called a seminar, “Marxism on Vedanta”, in which Dange had to confess his errors and cat crow. Deshpande’s book published by a society in Bombay was withdrawn from circulation.

The methods which Communism employs in India to denigrate and denounce the votaries of positive nationalism are the standard Communist methods it uses everywhere around the world. Here we shall concretise three of its chief methods under Indian conditions:
1. Communism in India has developed a language which George Orwell has described as doublespeak. In this language, the traitorous and totalitarian forces represented by the Communist movement are presented as patriotic and democratic forces, collaborators with Communism as progressive people, Islamic imperialism as secularism, and positive nationalism as Hindu communalism and chauvinism.........

2. Communism in India constantly practises what Karl Popper so aptly expounded “as the conspiracy theory of society”. It goes on digging up one conspiracy after another .....it links up “Hindu communalism and chauvinism” with capitalism, landlordism, .... finally, all of them with “American imperialism”. The forces of “democracy and progress” are then called upon to rally round the Communist movement to defeat the “grand conspiracy between American imperialism outside and reactionary Hindu communalism within”. ......

3. Communism in India wields a strong-worded swearology... that will illumine the venom which it can carry. During the Ranadive party-line in 1948-50, Mahatma Gandhi was “unmasked” as the cleverest bourgeois scoundrel and Rabindranath as măgeer dălăl, that is, a pimp. But the choicest reprimand was reserved for Sardar Patel and Pandit Nehru “the fascist duo”. Parichaya, the prestigious Bengali monthly, came out with a long poem on the two of them “conspiring together in the service of American imperialism”. One of the lines exposed them as shyălă shooarer băcchă, birlă tatăr jăroja shontăna, that is, sons of swine and the bastard progeny of Birlas and Tatas. ....At present, the bulk of Communist swearology is being mobilised against the camp of positive nationalism. People belonging to this camp are being daily denounced as communalists, chauvinists, fascist murderers of minorities, perpetrators of genocide, reactionaries and revivalists. .......

Hindu society is basically a sane society which can smile with tolerance at every variety of venomous as well as tall talk. ....Communism has, of course, fattened itself on widespread Macaulayism and a negative nationalism driven by nothing better than an anti-Western animus and inflated ideas about India’s role in world affairs. ....This is not the place to identify the channels through which the Soviet Union finances its fifth-column in India.

Here we are concerned with what the Communist movement does with this money. The following deserve our particular attention:
1. The Communist movement in India has built up the largest press in English as well as Indian languages. .....

2. The movement controls the largest number of publishing houses. .... ....A new line is publication of text-books, particularly on Indian history. These are prescribed by Communist professors whenever and wherever they control university departments, which is not unoften. Departments of history in the Delhi and Jawaharlal Nehru universities, for instance, have become pocket boroughs of Communism for all practical purposes. ......

3. The movement is a cadre-based movement. It has a farflung hierarchy of leaders and workers. All of them are paid activists. .....

4. The movement maintains and mans many front organisations among trade unions, peasantry, students, youth, women, children, writers, artists, for “peace”, for fighting “imperialism”, for opposing “communalism”. Most of these front organisations have their own offices and their own staff. ........

5. The Communist movement in India is well-known for the frequency of conferences, congresses, mass meetings and demonstrations. ......

We are not counting the routine expenses which every political movement or party has to incur in its normal functioning. The parties which do not control a government know it very well how difficult it is to find finances even for these normal expenses. The expenses incurred by the Communist movement are abnormal when compared to its size and significance in India’s body-politic. .....

The one thing which, next to slogans, never gets scarce in the Communist movement is money. That is how it is always in a position to prove that it is a movement of the poor, maintained by the poor, and for the benefit of the poor. Shankar had once drawn a cartoon in which a well-dressed upper class Communist worker was demanding a donation for peace from a naked and blind beggar, and denouncing the latter as a warmongering agent of American imperialism who would not part with his paisa.

 
 
Dahyabhai

Letter from Vrin Parker re Prof Thapar

May 4 2003, 5:28 AM 

Letter from Vrin Parker re Prof Thapar
From: Vrin Parker <vrnparker@yahoo.com>
Here is a letter I wrote to SACW in regards to their libelous statements against me. Vrn

http://www.hvk.org/articles/0503/0.html

Dear SACW Members and Whom it Concerns,

Its truly amazing to see the accusations of slander and Hindu right wing fundamentalists conspiracy being applied to me.

I started this petition on my own. No one asked me to or even urged me to do it. I actually am amazed at how much credit is given to the Hindu activists.Fine people as individuals but in general, Hindus are very unispiring campaigners and activists.

I found out about the R Thapar appointment from a Hindu friend. It was his and the usual lack of an action plan that I see amongst Hindus that caused me to stand up and say," I don't have to accept this. I, for one, am doing something about it." That is the honest genesis of the petition.

The truth is, I am a white American who lived and studied in India and in the USA. After having been forced to learn a lot misinformation about India in American schools I became fed up. I proved to my teacher that it was innacurate info. Simple but false statements like Kali yuga is named after the horrific Goddess Kali. Buddhism predates Hinduism. India was never a civilization because they didn't always have a unified state.

Her response was," You will be graded on what is in the books, so I would focus on that instead of worrying about what Hindus believe about their own culture." I began my own research and soon discovered that it was the Indians themselves, esp Romila Thapar, who are at the root of all the nonsense taught about Hindus in the West.(Of course thats my opinion and I have a right to it.)

As an American, I am very discouraged by the US Library of Congress using American resources and prestige to bolster the inaacuracies of Romila Thapar's research. I take great offense at being labelled by your group as a Hindu rightwing fundamentalist.

In fact, I am a private US citizen, practicing my constitutional rights of legally appealing to my elected representatives and other US government bodies involved in this issue.

By labelling me as a Hindu Right wing fundamentalist and accusing me of slandering Romila Thapar you have committed a libelous act.

http://www.mnet.fr/aiindex/Alerts/IDRT300403.html

I would like an apology and a retraction of your statements. I would also like to see you remove your libelous statements form the internet.

I am sorry if you don't agree with me or my actions against Thapar. That does not give you a right to attack my reputation.

The fact is you are acting fanatically and your reaction is very revealing. How many times have innocent people been demonized by your inapropriate name-calling? Is this type of situation the basis of all the anti-hindu reports going on in the world media? Are there people with a vested interest in denigrating Hinduism based on a need to create a more conducive atmosphere for conversion to Christianity? More converts, more money? Whats up?

What ever is going on you are definately out of line when publicly labelling a private US citizen. As an American, I value free speech and the right to dissent. By trying to demonize me and label me you are attempting to throttle my rights to dissent. If you don't agree with my opinion, as stated on the petition, than be honorable and democratic about it. Prove me wrong by using factual information.

Regardless of Romila Thapar's anti-Hindu bias or lack of it, I do not support her as a good use of our American resources. I need no reason to be against her except my constitutional right to freedom of speech. I expect a prompt response and clarification of your public and libelous statements against me.

Sincerely,
Brannon

 
 
Current Topic - Romila thappar appointment - US backed Marxist Assault on India's History  Respond to this message   
  << Previous Topic | Next Topic >>Return to Index  
Create your own forum at Network54
 Copyright © 1999-2009 Network54. All rights reserved.   Terms of Use   Privacy Statement  
iVarta.com Discussion Forum. at India News, Classifieds, Yellowpages, Business Listing, Yellow Pages or at India News, Classifieds, Yellowpages, Business Listing, Yellow Pages, Online Tickets