6th Sense - Loved it
Unbreakable - Huge letdown when I first say it, subsequent viewings later and I like it alright
Signs - Loved it
The Village - Vomit
Lady in the Water - Vomit
I liked the first two pretty good, and I haven't seen the last two however the middle one, Signs, I think that is the closest to a comedy M. Night might get. I actually laughed out loud a couple times in the theater including when he chopped the aliens fingers off. Something about Mel Gibson Screaming like a woman then abruptly de-fingering an alien struck a chord and tickled the old funny bone.
(Thanks to Todd for unlocking my account, I knew you'd come through for me)
And every time I see this movie mentioned, I get The Supremes song stuck in my head and get the giggles. I would really like to see that trailer recut with this song: