I do feel that so many accounts of corporal punishment at school on various sites and fora do seem to be of somewhat doubtful authenticity. The postings start off quite reasonably and are interesting but, presumably as the writer gets more and more "worked up", lurid exaggerations creep in and I lose interest.
I was taught at Prep School by Irish (very un-)Christian Brothers who have a certain reputation for excesses when it comes to the CP stakes. But even there, where it was freely available, no-one to my knowledge had to remove an article of clothing to get beaten. OK, so the gym master used to slipper on shorts but nothing worse.
Unfortunately the strap was usually given on the hands so there was no leavening of the proceedings by the crypto-erotic use of the strap on the backside to titillate the rest of us boys. In fact it was all too real, painful and guilt ridden so I avoided it like the plague. Even the smelly maths master who used to use the edge of a ruler on the bottom managed to conspire to make it an unpleasant experience ... 
Anyway, maybe keep the grosser exaggerations for stories and stick to the facts for these supposedly factual accounts?
Thanks
Paul
Paul's web page:
http://www.cpcp.me.uk ... e-mail:
mail@cpcp.me.uk