I've noticed recently that a lot of posts on corporal punihsment have been appearing on the many non-spanking forums I read.
What surprises me though is it is very clear to me that the original post is a fake story which seems to be there just as a way of getting genuine accounts of corporal punishment from the other non spanking enthusiast posters in reply.
These discussions seem to provoke some interesting post from people who have no idea that the original poster is a fake and genuine stories are promptly recounted.
Unlike other forums like this one the replying posters have no agenda of their own and the stories of their encounters with CP in their schooldays sound 100% genuine.
In contrast the accounts I've read on spanking themed forums always have the same tell tale signs of fantasy that the original poster on these forums always have, but the replying posts are often really fascinating.

What really surprises me though is how someone who is obviously in the know or has rumbled the original poster, always seems to turns just as it's getting interesting and basically stops the debate by informing forum members that the original post was a fantasist.
What I want to know is why would anyone with an interest in spanking actually do that, what’s in it for them?
Why would they loose a genuinely intriguing chance to hear about the genuine school punishment, which these people actually experienced?

And yet be happy to spend hour after hour day after day debating the subject with other enthusiasts just as caught up in the fantasy element as themselves?

Actually I did read one like that recently, which was quite good. A woman came on and described how her father had very occasionally spanked her when she was a kid if she was really bad.

She also noted how glad she was that she didn't have her best friends dad as a father as he used to whip her with a belt when she was bad.

It was very refreshing to read comments like that, which feature no lilaceous detail or spanko in-jokes and knowing that the contributor had no interest in spanking beyond it being a talking point of a Coronation street forum or something.

Why was the last post on this thread removed? I read it but don't remember anything that terrible having been writen in it.

So why has it gone?

Jolly Roger/New Poster:

We can allow you to have two pseudonyms, but not three, especially when the third is the name used by one of our most distinguished contributors.

A fair cop guvnor !!

SC

PS: Hey Jolly Roger - do you know wht pirates are called pirates ?

Because they arrrrrrrrrrr.

Here are three forums of a general nature where corporal punishment is discussed occasionally.

http://chat.dailymail.co.uk/dailymail/index.jsp


http://www.femalefirst.co.uk/board/forum-10.html


http://www.tes.co.uk/section/staffroom/list_threads.aspx?path=/behaviour/ (Kinky teachers and non-kinky teachers)

Here are the views of some of the women writing about the return of corporal punishment to schools on a Virginmedia board at

http://boards.virginmedia.com/shout/haveyoursay/corporalpunishment.html?page=1


Kitty from Surrey says:
Thoughout my schooling in the 70/80's the cane for the boys & the slipper for the girls was a threat, which made us tow the line. In my whole schooling I only know of the cane being administered a handful of times & the slipper- never. However the threat of humilation was present & if I had received it I would not have told my parents as they would have backed the school wholeheartedly.
Unfortunately the human rights but no responsiblities brigade will never allow this to return.

Vicky Witton from Staffordshire says:
I don't think it was so much the act of being caned, but the shame of it, as another viewer said. Now adays kids do not feel any fear or respect for adults whatsoever and so they would not feel shame - only anger and feelings of revenge. most teachers now would feel at risk not only froma vengeful pupil, but from his/her gang and the parents. what if the school were taken to court to prove that the caning were justified? Now the power is in the parents and pupils hands and no longer in the school or teachers. Some of the teachers aren't the best either - I noticed that one of the worst spellers on this site was a teacher! I think a good punishment is to not allow them out at break times but make them sit alone at all times until school finishes. make them work in all this time - either lines or some kind of written work - maybe why they think they are the way they are. if they get violent or abusive at any time the police should be able to be called in.

Chrissie from Birmingham says:
Surely someone must have noticed how awful some of the youngsters of today are? I really think that todays youth behave as they do, because of a lack if dicipline at home and at school.Perhaps if they knew they could be caned, slippered they would have a better out look on life, and be better citizens for it.The threat of the cane was always there when I went to school tho' I never received it. The threat and the thought of the embarrasment were more than enough.

Linda from Poole says:
Definitely not. I went to a strict catholic school where the cane was used on a daily basis for any transgressions and as a punishment for getting answers wrong. This is child abuse, I went from being a happy bright child to a nervous fearful wreck and started playing truant because I was so scared

Susie from Erith Kent says:
I think the cane or slipper should be legalised again in our schools.
I think the generation of today have no respect. I do think though it should be implemented in a controlled way and that there should be adult witnesses present, possibly two others to ensure that this is done properly and that the use of the cane or slipper is not abused.
Alternatively a CCTV Camera used to record the punishment to enable authorites to check at a future date that the punishments were all carried out properly. The reason why I think the Punishment should be implemented these ways are because there are good people and there are bad people and that applies to Adults as well as Kids.


There is also a discussion about domestic smacking

http://boards.virginmedia.com/shout/haveyoursay/smacking.html

The problem is that I doubt if there are any teachers who would be capable of administering it. Either too hard or too soft.

"The problem is that I doubt if there are any teachers who would be capable of administering it. Either too hard or too soft."

Are you referring to their penises?

Cannot imagine many female teachers with them mind you though some of those female PE teachers with hairy legs and chests come to mind.

i believe we should not use this as a form of disciplinary action to our children or pupils. I can relate in this because im a teacher. however, it is so difficult yet we should not practice this. its breaching child's rights. I hope the state would initiate new or alternative to CP.