<< Previous Topic | Next Topic >>Return to Index  

Youtube.com

November 4 2007 at 7:20 AM
Research Assistant 2 

 
Those with an interest in M/m will want to see two videos sent in by our distinguished contributor, Dr. Dominum.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EmoGZgaNH8Q

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sEAlVi4aaUE


 
 Respond to this message   
AuthorReply
beanokid

Re: Youtube.com

November 6 2007, 2:58 PM 

does anyone know the sources of these excellent pieces of historical re-enactment?

 
 
Doctor Dominum

Re: Youtube.com

November 7 2007, 9:00 AM 

Well, seeing the clips have been mentioned here, I suppose I should probably give the context behind their posting.

Over the years I've been asked by a number of people to try and describe how canings are administered in the modern day, as compared to how they used to be administered. Some people have even suggested I should record a caning, an idea with so many problems behind it, it's not even worth listing them all.

But recently, somebody took a different approach, through my schoolcp discussion list, and these video clips have been posted as part of that approach.

I'll copy and paste in the messages that I sent to my list, when these two videos were posted.

The first:

This is somewhat against my better judgement - however, we'll give it a try.

Over recent weeks I have found myself in private e-mail communication
with a self confessed spanking fetishist who strongly disapproves of
the use of corporal punishment in schools, and who stated he was
trying to understand my position about something he feels caused him
to develop a fetish.

As part of the discussion, he wanted to figure out what a caning is
actually like today. And to this end, he showed me a significant
number of videos, from television and film, and also some from
corporal punishment related pornography (nothing particularly graphic
at my request - merely things that might approximate what really
happens or happened in schools) to see if we could find something that
I agreed matched what I impose today.

We finally came up with the following video:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sEAlVi4aaUE

I believe this is a reasonably accurate representation of what a
'normal caning' is like today. It's not perfect - I would normally
have a boy bend over a chair or desk, rather than just touch his toes,
especially for a six stroke caning - but in terms of how hard I cane,
and the actions involved, in terms of how long it takes, I think it's
pretty accurate.

Most boys would react more than the young man in the film. He takes
this caning remarkably well in comparison to most boys. Given the
source, this may be because he finds it enjoyable, or just because he
is a little older, or simply because it's not a real punishment and so
the psychological issues involved may be different. But it's still
fairly accurate - and there are some boys who would react in this way.

I am informed that this video is produced by, for want of a better
word, a reputable producer of fetish material and therefore there is
no concern about the age of the people involved - the young man is
quite young, but must be over 18.

I realise that posting this material has copyright implications, and
so I don't intend to leave it up for a very long period. It's also a
small clip from a longer piece. It's offered for illustrative purposes
only.

Though it is fetishistic material, it does not involve nudity,
otherwise it would hardly be representative of a modern punishment.

I have to say, having found myself viewing some of the fetish material
out there, I really cannot see how anybody finds such material
enjoyable - I certainly do not. And very, very little of it seems to
be accurate. This piece is quite exceptional.

And the second:

In consultation with my aforementioned correspondent, we have located
another video that may interest people here.

This video, I feel, gives a fairly accurate impression of what 'six of
the best' was like up to about the early 1990s, in terms of timing,
severity, etc.

To visualise six of the best today, try imagining strokes as severe as
those administered in the previous video I shared, but administered in
the style - timing, general approach, etc - of this new video.

I probably don't take quite as long with most six of the best
canings, but there are some where I would, if I really want to make a
strong impression.

This video is, once again, drawn from a fetish source, but contains no
nudity, or similar, at least in this section.

The section that did contain nudity is probably fairly similar to the
few canings of that type I administered decades ago, but I really do
not want to share such material.

The 'boy's' reaction is also reasonably realistic, though I'd say that
this was an unusually tough boy. Perhaps a third of senior boys would
have taken such a caning as well as he does, and two thirds not as
well.

Repeating the same statement from the end of my first illustration post:

I am informed that this video is produced by, for want of a better
word, a reputable producer of fetish material and therefore there is
no concern about the age of the people involved - the young man is
quite young, but must be over 18.

I realise that posting this material has copyright implications, and
so I don't intend to leave it up for a very long period. It's also a
small clip from a longer piece. It's offered for illustrative purposes
only.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EmoGZgaNH8Q

 
 
KK

Comparison with reality

November 21 2007, 6:31 PM 

I would be interested to hear what those with personal experience of real high school canings make of these videos and more particularly, the force of the strokes and the severity of the punishment. It might be helpful to indicate the decade and country of your experience when making comparisons.

 
 
winston.

Re: Youtube.com

November 21 2007, 11:14 PM 

I am from S'pore,i got the cane before,i would says the caning is much more harder here.

 
 
KK

Winston

November 23 2007, 5:49 AM 

Winston, I understand you are a high school student and that you have been caned recently on more than one occasion. Please confirm.

 
 
winston

Re: Youtube.com

November 23 2007, 1:43 PM 

yes,comfirmed.

 
 
KK

Singapore high school versus Australia

November 23 2007, 6:48 PM 

Winston, In your opinion are the canings in the video hard enough to be an effective punishment?

 
 
winston

Re: Youtube.com

November 23 2007, 11:19 PM 

Not really....the cane used is too thin & short.

 
 
c. farrell

caning comparisons

November 25 2007, 11:11 AM 

Well, readers can judge for themselves: I have uploaded 2 brief clips of real Singapore school canings at http://www.corpun.com/vidsc9.htm , which, I am given to understand, are fairly typical of current practice there.

Perhaps Winston could let us know how this compares with his own experience.

As for the acted-out scene to which Dr Dominum draws our attention, the strokes look pretty feeble to me. Presumably the filmmakers don't want to cause the actor playing the "schoolboy" much real pain.

I'm interested that Dr D thinks this typical of current Australian practice, or what little there is left of it. My subjective impression is that canings in England were typically given a good deal harder than this, especially perhaps at boys' secondary schools, like the very ordinary local grammar school I went to in the early 1960s.

 
 
winston

Re: Youtube.com

November 25 2007, 11:15 AM 

Yeah,my caning is almost the same,got 3 strokes.Here,it is common,that every stroke,the student will 'jump' up & rub his buttocks....

 
 
KK

Cane marks

November 25 2007, 11:36 PM 

I think it is difficcult to judge the force of the strokes from a video. Perhaps the marks made are a better indicator?

Winston, when you were caned how long did the marks last?

 
 
winston

Re: Youtube.com

November 26 2007, 12:21 PM 

3 days.!

 
 
Danny

Re: Youtube.com

December 13 2007, 8:58 PM 

The two videos you have shown here, Doc, are very realistic and memories of years long-gone almost send shivers up my back!

 
 
Current Topic - Youtube.com  Respond to this message   
  << Previous Topic | Next Topic >>Return to Index  
Find more forums on SchoolsCreate your own forum at Network54
 Copyright © 1999-2014 Network54. All rights reserved.   Terms of Use   Privacy Statement