Thank you,
Ketta. As ever on this estimable Forum the voice of reason. You are absolutely correct in saying that modern children find themselves in a very stressful environment. I frequently say in conversation that I would not like to be young now. I don't think the world is going to treat those now at school as well as it has treated my generation.
I have to differ though on the question of school corporal punishment and its applicability today. There is, I know, absolutely no imminent prospect of CP returning. However if it did I believe it would have decided beneficial effects up to around age 12 or 13. It was the ultimate sanction which enabled the excellent teachers I had in primary school (at that time junior school) to teach classes of 50 plus from which every child (in my class at least) emerged able to cope with quick-fire questions on their 12 times table.
I was horrified to discover that now, despite class numbers being down to 20 or so, around 40% of children exit primary school unable to deal with even the 6 times table! Not a good omen for the increasingly technological future and the competion from countries where children are still properly taught by traditional methods. The decline here, in my opinion anyway, is down to classroom discipline. Even where there are good teachers, they can't teach because they have to deal with too many issues of anger management - or rather the lack of it! Quickly dealt with and put aside to enable the serious teaching to continue in my day!
Steve, a most pertinent comment when you say "It only bothered teachers if it involved hitting girls or bullying". No boy would have hit a girl when I was young. We had a curious double standard though, because we didn't think it particularly unusual if an adult male, parent or teacher, did. Possibly the distinction was between fists and open hands or punishment implements. Or maybe we just accepted that adults could do what they liked. Weird but it somehow worked!
Nobody kicked in fights either, you'd have been totally ostracised. It bothers me when I see little lads kicking each other, let alone kicking girls. Mind you, these days the girls seem quite capable of kicking back!
Your final sentence leads me to give you my nomination as the Civil Servant I would most like to see promoted to take total charge of all those government departments engaged in disbursing my hard earned cash to the less deserving elements of society. And there's no smiley after that, so I'm serious!