And yes I know Clivia well. And I'll definitely try the Paella.
As an alternative, next time ask them to make you a Zarzuela. It's a Catalan fish dish that is simply mindblowing. It's not on the menu but if you order 24 hours ahead, he'll give you a knowing grin and choose some fish specifically. There's no price, it all depends what he pays...but it's worth it.
I like the look of the seafood restaurant...where was that...Cala Pi?