PMs face off
Howard, Somare in confrontation over seasonal labour issue
By PHILBERT AISAISA
AUSTRALIAN Prime Minister John Howard flew home last night only hours after an abrupt exchange with Sir Michael Somare in his capacity as chairman of the Pacific Islands Forum.
The incident took place after Tuvalu’s Prime Minister Maatia Toafa made some remarks about the refusal of Australia and New Zealand to consider taking in seasonal labour from other Pacific Island nations.
In a leaders’ session at Crowne Plaza, Mr Toafa said many Pacific Islands students attended universities in Australia and they had not violated any visa regulations, challenging the suggestion by Mr Howard and New Zealand Prime Minister Helen Clark about their fears of increased level of illegal migrants.
He asked why citizens from the United States and Europe were allowed to take up manual jobs in Australia, while people from the Pacific were barred.
Mr Howard immediately moved to reply, but Sir Michael stopped him.
Observers said Mr Howard shook his head and became red in the face, asking Sir Michael if he was going to allow the criticism to stand.
“I will not allow you to reply and I will not entertain your comments,” Sir Michael responded.
Showing obvious dissatisfaction with the ruling, Mr Howard moved away from the microphone.
Sir Michael then changed his mind and asked Mr Howard to provide a brief response, as the Tuvalu Prime Minister’s comments had effectively been the end of the meeting.
Mr Howard gave a short response to say that the case of the United States and Europe was different because people from these countries entered Australia on a “Holiday Maker Visa” which was quite different from the “seasonal labour” idea.
Mr Howard walked out of the meeting and was unavailable for further comments, but Sir Michael assured the media there was no standoff between them.
“We are good friends and I’ve worked with them (Australians) for over 30 years and I know them,” he said. “There is no disagreement between us.”
There has been unanimous demand from developing PIF member countries that Australia and New Zealand open up the country to workers from the Pacific, a stance that was supported by Australian policy makers at a meeting yesterday at the University of Sydney.
Mr John Connel of Sydney University said seasonal worker schemes were the “most effective way of boosting living standards in Pacific countries”.
The two Prime Ministers had also clashed at the previous Pacific Islands Forum meeting when Mr Howard broke the usual protocol to insist that an Australian be appointed as secretary general of the group, against the wishes of Sir Michael.
Until then the PIF secretary general had always come from one of the developing member countries of the forum.
Meanwhile, A World Bank report has accused Australia of being the worst culprit in terms of the brain drain from neighbouring Pacific Island nations.
It said that more than 75 per cent of all graduates from Tonga and Samoa and 62 per cent of graduates from Fiji had emigrated, mostly to Australia and New Zealand.
Australia was cited as a country that had pioneered the migration of skilled workers, a policy that was spreading around western countries.
http://www.thenational.com.pg/1028/nation1.htm
Sir Michael ... refuses to entertain Mr Howard’s response.
n Mr Howard ... shakes his head in dissatisfaction. — AAPpics