When you win ONE World Series of Handicapping let alone TWO then and only then will I weigh your opinion seriously.
Or when you have 45 years of hands on handicapping will I value your opinion in a class with Steven Davidowitz.
Colin is forgotten because of MOW! MOW erased both Sysonby and Colin from history.
Colin set track records mostly on straight courses against one opponent.
Colin`s best speed figure The Champagne Oct 19 1907 was 107 on Belmont Straight course against one horse Stamina!
Colin`s best Saratoga race Aug 10 1907 and he equaled the track record of 1:12 running against one horse named Uncle who pressed him very hard. 104 Beyer that day.
People kept accurate daily speed variants even then. I have uncovered records extant of day to day speed variants of that time.
Colin was a great two year old but is much slower than either Regret or Ruffian.
via a vis Ruffian`s best Spa time 1:08 3/5 on slow track 109 beyer 6fl
Colin`s best Spa time 1:12 fast track 104 Beyer 6 fl
There is not a 3 second difference in the basic speed of the two tracks between 1907 and 1974. On average there is a two second difference which leaves Ruffian 4 to 5 lengths better than Colin.