I say this not because I don't like Matt and Maxie, because I do like them. They have a good spark together, however, I see spark between Spin/Max as well.
The reason I say characters need chemistry along with the actors' chemistry is because GH has a history of putting characters who used to a part of other soaps' supercouples in order to capitalize on the former couple's popularity. GH has failed at these attempts in the past. Stephen Nichols as Stefan Cassadine and Mary Beth Evans as Katherine Bell did not work. Nancy Lee Grahn as Alexis Davis and Lane Davies as Dr. Cameron Lewis did not work, even though they had worked on Santa Barbara as Julia Wainwright Capwell and Mason Capwell. Both of these pairings clearly worked on the original soap chemistry wise, but did work in their second pairing on different shows in different situations.
The Stefan/Katherine pairing didn't work, in my opinion, because Stefan was a complicated character who didn't do well with the traditional soap opera love story. There are other reasons as well, but I thought Stefan worked more as a stand alone character than he did with any pairing. The pairing also didn't make sense in that neither character was in each other spheres/storylines than suddenly they were together.
As for Nancy Lee Grahn/Lane Davies, they were a boring pairing on GH. This may have been in part due to the fact that the writers seemed to avoid writing for Cameron Lewis. If written correctly with Nancy and Chad Brannon, who played his son - Zander, I think the character of Cameron Lewis would have been more interesting.
Now, if Matt and Maxie get together on GH, I'm not saying they won't work, I'm just saying that the characters and the actors need to be right in order for the pairing to work. It's a bit early to tell, but at the moment, the actors and characters are sparking. The writers need to be careful how they proceed so that they don't end up with the failures I mentiones above. I think a slow build is a good idea for them, even if other pairings come before the pairing of Matt and Maxie for awhile.
Lissie
Lissie's Fics:
http://www.network54.com/Forum/181424