montegrappa or dunhill?

Hello,

I have a quetsion about 2 pens :


1) Montegrappa cigar

What do you think of the Montegrappa cigar pen?

Isn't it too thick to write ?

Do collectors like it ?

How much did it cost in 1997 brand new ?

How much can I get it brand new now ?


2) Dunhill sentrymen roller with diamond pettern

Good pen ?

Made by who ?


Thanks