My favourite is the butter ball cause it's so moisturizing, it contains little bits of cocoa butter. But you really have to go by your personal scent preferences, cause they're all great.
I tested the floating island (one of the bath melts) too and liked it, but missed the sparkling effect that makes the bath bombs so much fun.
I also like the massage bars, but would stick to the uncoloured ones (the chocolate massage bars feel and smell nice, but they stain skin and sheets). I just bought the Wiccy Magic Muscles which
I haven't had the pleasure of experiencing yet, but my b/f sure loves me massageing him with it

And I enjoy the nice scent on him afterwards
I also have Buffy The Backside Slayer, a moisturizing / exfoliating bar that I enjoy a lot if I have the time to indulge in a long shower. Also great as a final treatment after an elaborate pedicure.
Do I sound like a commercial or what

Seriously, so far I haven't bought anything from Lush I didn't like. I haven't tried their facial products cause I'm happy with the stuff I use and don't want to mess with a running system. Nor have I used any of their hair care products, but I have the Arabian Bright treatment sitting on the shelf waiting for its turn.
Lush products are addicting! I abused most of my sushi dishes (sashimi boards, soy sauce dishes and soup bowls) as Lush stuff containers. They look so nice in the bathroom and I can eat sushi from ordinary plates after all

Cheers,
Madeleine
--
Pixie/BS/waist (if it wants to grow that far)
1cFi, dark ash blonde hennaed fiery red
