--


  << Previous Topic | Next Topic >>Return to Index  

Ultra Boy and Sunspot

February 25 2004 at 5:54 AM
  (Login MikeSawin)
Byrne Victim

-
The Favorite Legion Member Thread brought to mind one of my pet peeves in comics. And since Ultra Boy and Sunspot (from the New Mutants) epitomize the problem...

Basically, it's this. Both are powerful guys who have an array of super-powers, but can only use one of those powers at a given time. Ultra Boy is a Daxamite, IIRC, with all the powers of Superman, and Sunspot is super strong and has some sort of heat-themed power.

So when they go into a fight, the storyteller has to find a way to let new readers know of the character's powers and limitations. In order to do this, bad writers always resort to one team mate yelling:

"Look out, Ultra Boy! You aren't invulnerable when you're using your super strength!"

or

"Look out, Sunspot! You're really strong, but you're not invulnerable!"

I am so far out of collecting that there's no way I can bring up issue numbers to back this up, but it happened so often that I quit reading the books.

Why in the world would someone announce out loud their friends weakness and limitations for the bad guys to hear?

And I don't think this is some sort sort fanboy nitpick on the order of how does Tony Stark go to the bathroom in his Iron Man suit.

I'll bet JB could write a scene with Ultra Boy (if he hasn't already)that shows the guy's power and vulnerability without resorting to that stupid move. Heck, I'm pretty sure I could.

(Although I'd probably have to use the narrator, or have the bad guys know that he's a Daxamite.)

"Watch Ultra Boy! When he uses his super strength, blast him with your plasma ray!"

Mike Sawin

Your Friendly Neighborhood PITA

 
 Respond to this message   
AuthorReply

(Login MAliChoudhury)

Re: Ultra Boy and Sunspot

February 25 2004, 7:46 AM 

And I don't think this is some sort sort fanboy nitpick on the order of how does Tony Stark go to the bathroom in his Iron Man suit.

I'm guessing he has a similar set up as fighter pilots.


Relief Bag
Though pilots also carry a supply of plastic bags for collecting drinking water in case they are downed, this particular bag serves another purpose. Using the zipper on the front of his uniform, a pilot can urinate into this bag in mid-air during long hauls. The plastic bag contains highly absorbent sponges.


http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/xplanes/outf-nf.html

cactusmaac

 
 

(Login bradexample)
Byrne Victim

Re: Ultra Boy and Sunspot

February 25 2004, 8:51 AM 

ultra boy isn't a daxamite, he's from rimbor.

bryan carney
http://www.bryancarney.com

 
 


(Login davecarr)
Byrne Victim

Re: Ultra Boy and Sunspot

February 25 2004, 9:57 AM 

Why in the world would someone announce out loud their friends weakness and limitations for the bad guys to hear?

This is where thought balloons come in handy. However, the "cinematic" qualities of comics contrast with the use of thought balloons, and they are beginning to die off.




David Alan Carr
http://www.atlscript.org

 
 

(Login MikeSawin)
Byrne Victim

Thought balloons

February 25 2004, 10:59 AM 

Okay,I'll guive you thought balloons....but I believe that there is a much more dramatic and dynamic way of getting the point across without a character or the narrator just out and out telling us every freakin issue that Ultra Boy can only use one power at a time.

Mike Sawin

Your Friendly Neighborhood Pain In The Ass

Insert Clever Signature here!

 
 

(Login MAliChoudhury)

Re: Ultra Boy and Sunspot

February 25 2004, 11:34 AM 

I'd have thought somebody would have found a way to depict the current power being used visually instead of using expostion.

cactusmaac

 
 

(Login CoreyJohnson)
Byrne Victim

Re: Ultra Boy and Sunspot

February 25 2004, 12:45 PM 

Marvel has been doing those "introductory" pages which sometimes briefly detail the various character's abilities.

 
 
Current Topic - Ultra Boy and Sunspot  Respond to this message   
  << Previous Topic | Next Topic >>Return to Index  
 Copyright © 1999-2008 Network54. All rights reserved.   Terms of Use   Privacy Statement  
All commentary, artwork and other materials posted to this site by JB are © John Byrne Inc and/or the respective copyright holders. Nothing may be reproduced, in whole or in part, without the express written consent of John Byrne and/or the respective copyright holders.

Some other sites you might enjoy ...

JB's Art Dealer (purchase original comic art directly from the source!)
JB's Computer-Rendered Art Showcase at the Strata Café
JB's UGO Column (JB opinionates on various comic-related topics)
The JB Master Checklist
Discount Comic Book Service (New issues by mailorder)
CDisplay (Freeware ECB reader)
The Roger Stern Message Board (featuring participation by JB's good friend, Mr Stern himself!)
Fred Hembeck's Website
The Steve Ditko Playgroup