<< Previous Topic | Next Topic >>Return to Index  

What the hell did Diddy buy?? - 4.28.04

April 28 2004 at 1:08 PM

  (Login BobS620)
Negative Mod

 
...I need guidance!!



~Bob

 
 Respond to this message   
AuthorReply

b. diddly
(Login b_diddy)
Byrne Victim

what did or didn't diddly do?

April 28 2004, 1:37 PM 

sorry, preparing for my first ever court case tomorrow morning. yay.

 Abadazad #3 (really cool idea, though i wonder if it will go bye-bye due to CrossGen's uncertain future)
 
 Conan #3 (ok, i said i was dropping it but will give it another try)

 Daredevil Father #1 (go ahead, mock me, i like Quesada's art)

 Flash #209 (Geoff Johns is the man)

 Incredible Hulk #71 (first time i've bought a Hulk comic in years... but a cool, retro cover and a battle against Iron Man has me intrigued)

 JLA #97 (obviously)

 Mystique #13 (Brian K. Vaughan's last issue, and thus mine)
 
 Superman #204 (first Superman comic I've bought in probably 15 years!!!)

 Ultimate Fantastic Four #5 (i really want to like this but it's only good some of the time)
 
 Ultimate Six #7 (last issue... very disappointing mini series)

 X-Statix #22 (loving the X-Statix/Avengers war... it's like the DEFENDERS VS THE AVENGERS meets SPOCK'S BRAIN... good stuff... though i hear this is the last arc before the title gets canceled?!?)

 
 

Dan Marcoux
(Login DanMarcoux)
Byrne Victim

Marvel Age titles

April 28 2004, 1:49 PM 

Has anyone picked up any of the Marvel Age titles? I leafed through a couple at the local "book and record" store (the kids still laugh at me when I refer to a place as a record store) and was ......intrigued?...... Looks like original Stan Lee stories, but with new dialog and art?

 
 

Anonymous
(Login johnbyrne)
The Chief

Re: What the hell did Diddy buy?? - 4.28.04

April 28 2004, 1:59 PM 

Daredevil Father #1 (go ahead, mock me, i like Quesada's art)


****************

Quesada is a good artist.

 
 

Tony
(Login Tvitale)
Byrne Victim

For moi.....

April 28 2004, 2:05 PM 

Ultimate six -7

Ultimate FF-5

Avengers/Thunderbolts -3

Birds of prey -66

JLA -97

Superman -204

Flash -209


that'll hold me for a week.

 
 


(Login ChrisHutton)
Byrne Victim

Re: What the hell did Diddy buy?? - 4.28.04

April 28 2004, 2:09 PM 

<Quesada is a good artist.>
Be that as it may, I didn't care for a DD the width of two people. I'm not a fan of steroids in comics.

 
 

Brendan Howard
(Login brenhow)

Re: What the hell did Diddy buy?? - 4.28.04

April 28 2004, 2:09 PM 

You hear that?! This John Byrne character has such an ego! He gives people compliments even when he has had negative professional experiences with them! He's a monster! The nerve....

Hey, wait a minute.

Ahem.

Let it never be said that JB can't separate the pro from their work.

Brendan Howard

 
 


(Login David_Poole)
Byrne Victim

All I needed to see of Joey Q's latest DD

April 28 2004, 2:26 PM 

Page 1:



No thanks.

 
 

b. diddly
(Login b_diddy)
Byrne Victim

david p.

April 28 2004, 2:31 PM 

wow, that IS pretty bad.

his DD relaunch art was much better. and his Origin covers were purty (my wife loves the cover to Origin #1).

 
 

(Login RonFarrell)
Byrne Victim

Re: What the hell did Diddy buy?? - 4.28.04

April 28 2004, 2:36 PM 

Flash (the randomly selected lunch time read. And a good one. )
JLA (of course)
Birds of Prey
Legion
Superman (giving the new team a shot)
Avengers vs. Thunderbolts




 
 


(Login MattReed)
Robotmod

Eric Lund's Purchases

April 28 2004, 2:44 PM 

Eric Lund's Famous Comic Purchases Thread -- 4.28.04
April 28 2004 at 2:32 PM
Eric Lund (Login EricLund)
Byrne Victim
from IP address 207.218.46.101

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Big week for me this week for a change!

Ultimate FF 5 Fighting the Mole Man
Hulk 71 Hulk vs Iron Man!
JLA 97 WOW!
Superman 204 Jim Lee
Flash 209 Like Porters' art
Conan 3 Like Cords' art
The Moth 1 Steve "The Dude" Rude
Ultimate Six 7 Last issue
Outsiders Trade of their first 7 issues Raney art is cool
(even though I am the Anti-Trade guy)


    
This message has been edited by MattReed on Apr 28, 2004 2:50 PM


 
 
Chris Workman
(Login TheColdEsq.)
Byrne Victim

Re: What the hell did Diddy buy?? - 4.28.04

April 28 2004, 3:07 PM 

Superman 204 (Jim Lee draws a great Superman and, so far, the story seems much better than Azzarello's incredibly boring Batman)
Batman 626
Birds of Prey 66
Ministry of Space 3
Caper 7 (this story, a legal drama, is not as the first arc, a gangster story, but it is pretty decent)
Wildcats 3.0 20
Conan 3
Mystique 13
X-Treme X-Men 46
Legion 32
JLA 97
Flash 209

 
 

Zaki
(Login ZakiHasan)
Byrne Victim

Re: What the hell did Diddy buy?? - 4.28.04

April 28 2004, 3:14 PM 

Slim week for me...

Superman 204
JLA 97
Batman Adventures 12
Essential Tomb of Dracula Vol. 2

On a somewhat related note, did any Universal Monster fans pick up the Legacy Collections that came out on DVD yesterday? 14 Classic Universal Monster movies on 6 discs! Highest recommendation for fans!

See my interview with
VIGGO MORTENSEN at
www.mrboyproductions.com

 
 
Keith Elder
(Login KeithElder)
Byrne Victim

Re: What the hell did Diddy buy?? - 4.28.04

April 28 2004, 3:17 PM 

Has anyone picked up any of the Marvel Age titles? I leafed through a couple at the local "book and record" store (the kids still laugh at me when I refer to a place as a record store) and was ......intrigued?...... Looks like original Stan Lee stories, but with new dialog and art?

---

I picked up the FF Marvel Age #1, and will probably buy the next few issues. The art is manga-style, which is ok with me. It was a fun comic, and made me remember how fast-paced the original FF stories were.

As long as they stick closely to the original stories, I think I'll buy them. My boys liked it a lot. I think it's a far better idea than the ultimate versions were.

-Keith

 
 

Brendan Howard
(Login brenhow)

Re: What the hell did Diddy buy?? - 4.28.04

April 28 2004, 3:37 PM 

Records are records, whether they are released on vinyl, cassette, 8-track, CD, minidisc, or digital download. Regardless of delivery device, they are recordings aka records. That's what the industry and the artists call them, and they should know!

It's only because vinyl was the dominant format for so long that turntables started to be known as "record players," which muddied the waters for all time once "tape players" and "CD players" came to be.

If Dave Matthews released an MP3-only concert recording, some of his fans who listened to it on their computer would probably say it's a "cool CD." They would be wrong, because it's not a CD. The fans who call it a "cool album" or a "cool record" would be accurate.

Brendan Howard

 
 


(Login MattReed)
Robotmod

Matt's Stack O' Books

April 28 2004, 3:58 PM 

Batman - 626 (Hope this is better than Winick's OUTSIDERS, which makes me want to take a shower)
The Flash - 209
JLA - 97
Hulk - 71
Ultimate Six - 7
Ultimate FF - 5
Avengers - 81
Catwoman - 30
Birds of Prey - 66
Superman - 204 (Like the diddster, this is the first time I've picked up a Superman title in a decade. Hope it lives up to the hype.)

Avengers/Thunderbolts - 3 (A customer in the store said he was buying this title even though it was "god-awful." So much wrong with that statement, I don't even know where to begin.)

X-Statix - 22
New Mutants - 13
Iron Man - 80 (Close to the chopping block on this title)
Conan - 3
Tales of the Vampires - 5
30 Days of Night: Return to Barrow - 2



Matt Reed


    
This message has been edited by MattReed on Apr 28, 2004 4:00 PM


 
 


(Login BobS620)
Negative Mod

Re: What the hell did Diddy buy?? - 4.28.04

April 28 2004, 4:50 PM 

...and I was just about to ask what the over/under was on Matt Reed's comic budget for the day!!

~Bob

 
 


(Login ChrisHutton)
Byrne Victim

Re: What the hell did Diddy buy?? - 4.28.04

April 28 2004, 7:57 PM 

OK, all y'all who bought Superman 204, plz report here with a "yay" or "nay"
I do like Jim Lee's art, but I don't want to suffer thru Azzarello if I don't have to

 
 
Leo Whitman
(Login LeoWhitman)
Byrne Victim

What the hell did Leo buy?? - 4.28.04

April 28 2004, 8:04 PM 

JLA 97... Good stuff.
Superman: Secret Identity #4

(Big week for me, believe it or not.)

 
 


(Login MattReed)
Robotmod

Re: What the hell did Diddy buy?? - 4.28.04

April 28 2004, 9:07 PM 

OK, all y\'all who bought Superman 204, plz report here with a \"yay\" or \"nay\"
I do like Jim Lee\'s art, but I don\'t want to suffer thru Azzarello if I don\'t have to


I give it a \"yea.\" Not as convoluted as his Batman arc, this story is the foundation of what looks to be a very different Superman story...and that\'s a good thing compared to the crud his titles have been for over a decade. I\'m not entirely sure where it\'s going but, if the rest of the issues are as good as this one, I\'m along for the ride. And Lee\'s art is just nice to look at.



Matt Reed

 
 


(Login HealthyColours)
Byrne Victim

Re: The Flash

April 28 2004, 10:30 PM 

I have seen so many positive posts regarding The Flash and Geoff Johns of late that it has really gotten me curious. Is there a particular arc of the Geoff Johns Flash that makes a good sampler? How far back does his run go?

 
 
James Taylor
(Login LightningMan)
Byrne Victim

Re: What the hell did Diddy buy?? - 4.28.04

April 28 2004, 11:17 PM 

For Geoff Johns on Flash, reading #209 by itself is a good start (it was my first.) It's really complete in one issue (with plot threads, of course) and kind of explains where Flash has been the past several issues I didn't read.

 
 


(Login DanMarcoux)
Byrne Victim

Re: What the hell did Diddy buy?? - 4.28.04

April 29 2004, 12:32 AM 

OK, all y'all who bought Superman 204
My LCS owner must be expecting this book to be HUGE. He had 6X the shelf space devoted to this book as opposed to JLA's 2X (which was down from 3X for JLA 94).

(Texte du message? Ooohkaaay then...)

 
 

(Login DavidBarker)
Byrne Victim

Re: What the hell did Diddy buy?? - 4.28.04

April 29 2004, 8:46 AM 

I don't generally like Azzarello. I hated his Batman..I only suffered through 2 issues. I got bored with 100 Bullets halfway through the second Trade. That said, I liked the tone of Superman 204. I think he nailed Superman pretty well..unlike his Batman.

Flash is my favorite comic on the market and has been since Paul Gulacy took over the art on Catwoman. I can't read Catwoman at all now because of his art. Catwoman went from being my favorite book to unreadable because the art was so distracting to the flow of the story. Flash keeps getting better though.

I got...
Tom Strong Hardcover #3...
Flash 209...the best book in the superhero market.
Superman 204...I was surprised in a good way.
Birds of Prey 66...No Toth cover as solicited. Verrry mad.
Harley & Ivy 1... come on. Dini & Timm.
JLA 97...of course. Yay, we finally see them.really looking forward to the final 2 books.

 
 

Rob H
(Login RobHearn)
Byrne Victim

My weekly picks were...

April 29 2004, 11:37 AM 

JLA #97 (well, duh!) -- I though this was the weakest issue of the arc so far, which does NOT mean that it wasn't still a great read! I think it was the Wonder Woman stuff that threw me off. She seemed to recover pretty fast. Did I miss something there? However, seeing more of the DP was supah! Robotman looks real purdy!

4 #5 -- My only monthly M****l read. The art by McNiven is gorgeous! The writing has been getting better each issue. I would recommend this book for the art if nothing else.

Superman #204 -- YAWN. I don't know. I picked this up on an impulse. First Supes book for me in many moons. Story was adequate, but Jim Lee's art just does not grab me the way it seems to grab everyone alse. Great draftsman, but I find that if you see his work once or twice, you've basically seen it all. Never anything new.

Astro City/Arrowsmith Flip Book -- I missed this last week. Anyone read Arrowsmith? Any good? I'm a big fan of AC which is why I picked this up. Busiek is one of my favourite writers (along with JB and Johns).


 
 
Mike Brisbois
(Login HadjiWannabe)
Byrne Victim

Re: What the hell did Diddy buy?? - 4.28.04

April 29 2004, 4:08 PM 

b. diddy wrote: "sorry, preparing for my first ever court case tomorrow morning. yay."
_________________________________________

So, Diddy? Nu?

Here's hopes you flourished.

 
 

Dave Phelps
(Login Dave_Phelps)
Byrne Victim

Re: What the hell did Diddy buy?? - 4.28.04

April 29 2004, 4:23 PM 

Rather large week for me...

ABADAZAD #3
AVENGERS #496
AVENGERS THUNDERBOLTS #3
BATMAN #626
BATMAN HARLEY & IVY #1
BIRDS OF PREY #66
BONE #54
CATWOMAN #30
FLASH #209
GREEN LANTERN #176
INCREDIBLE HULK #71
JLA #97
KISS KISS BANG BANG #4
LEGION #32
SOJOURN #34
WAY OF THE RAT #23
WEAPON X #22
X-TREME X-MEN #46

 
 
Brian Czako
(Login BrianCzako)
Byrne Victim

X-Treme #46

April 29 2004, 4:34 PM 

Spoliers to those who haven't read X-Treme X-Men #46.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Um, when did Kitty and Rachel become lesbians? (Not that there's anything wrong with that.) There were a few scenes that seemed very out of character to me. Plus I'd always assumed that Rachel's short hair was because they shaved it when she was a hound.

Brian


 
 

The Mighty Mike N.
(Login ArgentFox)
Byrne Victim

Re: What the hell did Diddy buy?? - 4.28.04

April 29 2004, 5:39 PM 

Uh... since CC just pulled it out of his ASS!

Kitty was, up until this very issue, the poster child for rampant female Heterosexuality. Not only that, but she had what passes for stable relationships in the X-Universe. sigh

Well, yet another reason to not read the X-Books any longer.

Mike Nebeker - Super Genuis
Good Judgement comes from Experience and Experience comes from... Bad Judgement.

 
 

The Final Post as B. Diddy?
(Login b_diddy)
Byrne Victim

Mike B.

April 29 2004, 5:41 PM 

Postponed until August, which is fine with me.

 
 


(Login Trevah)
Byrne Victim

Re: What the hell did Diddy buy?? - 4.28.04

April 29 2004, 5:58 PM 

"Um, when did Kitty and Rachel become lesbians? (Not that there's anything wrong with that.) There were a few scenes that seemed very out of character to me. Plus I'd always assumed that Rachel's short hair was because they shaved it when she was a hound."

Maybe Rachel's mind-control powers are working overtime? I dunno...

 
 
Steve Merritt
(Login SteveMerritt)
Byrne Victim

Re: What the hell did Diddy buy?? - 4.28.04

April 29 2004, 9:41 PM 

X-treme X-Men #26

JLA #97 (will comment later on the offical thread)

Transformers #4 (Omega Supreme is back! Yes!)

Superman #204 (The art looks really, really good! The story was not so hot in my opinion. I wonder what the people who said JLA 94 was slow will say about this one!)

 
 

Dave Pruitt
(Login Dave_Pruitt)
Chairman Emeritus

Re: What the hell did Diddy buy?? - 4.28.04

April 30 2004, 12:05 AM 

Big week for me.

JLA 97

Flash 209

Conan 3

Bone 54 (next to last ish)

X-Statix 22

I bought the last ish of X-Statix (21) because that Mike Allred cover with the Avengers was just too, good. I bought the next ish too. I love Allred art, and the chance to see these characters drawn by him is too good to miss.

 
 

(Login btx109)
Byrne Victim

Re: What the hell did Diddy buy?? - 4.28.04

April 30 2004, 12:26 AM 

Am I the only person here who was incredibly underwhelmed by Superman #204?

YAWN...

 
 
Steve Merritt
(Login SteveMerritt)
Byrne Victim

Re: What the hell did Diddy buy?? - 4.28.04

April 30 2004, 12:52 AM 

The story underwhelmed me. But that may be because I've been reading Birthright and Superman/Batman which have a lot more action. I still enjoyed the issue as a whole though. I should have expected a grittier tale considering the author, but I just wanted to see a more traditional take.
The art was great. The colors were awesome. The outer space rescue sequence was good too. The scene with the atmosphere re-entry was well done! It made me imagine what it would be like to experience that myself.
I think the story will be better next issue. Let's all just keep our inner trolls on their leashes for a couple of issues.

One thing is for sure, the issue was MUCH slower than JLA #94. So I wonder if the same critics who criticized JLA #94 will say the same about SUperman.

 
 


(Login brihunt)
Byrne Victim

Re: What the hell did Diddy buy?? - 4.28.04

April 30 2004, 5:30 PM 

Igave Superman 204 a thumbs up. The art is good and the story seems to be starting at a point that has me wanting more. The pacing is good for adult readers, but probably too slow for younger ones (as with most comics these days. Sigh).

DD: Father was a better read than I expected. I almost didn't buy it because of the grotesque figure on the openning splash page, but luckily I thumbed the rest of the book and it really has a good look to it. Don't be thrown off by that one image.


Bought Ultimate Six #7 and yawned all the way through. This series should have stopped at #6. A whole issue just to wrap it up? I liked the premise, but too slow in the execution.

-Brian Hunt


 
 
Current Topic - What the hell did Diddy buy?? - 4.28.04  Respond to this message   
  << Previous Topic | Next Topic >>Return to Index  
 Copyright © 1999-2009 Network54. All rights reserved.   Terms of Use   Privacy Statement  
All commentary, artwork and other materials posted to this site by JB are © John Byrne Inc and/or the respective copyright holders. Nothing may be reproduced, in whole or in part, without the express written consent of John Byrne and/or the respective copyright holders.

Some other sites you might enjoy ...

JB's Art Dealer (purchase original comic art directly from the source!)
JB's Computer-Rendered Art Showcase at the Strata Café
JB's UGO Column (JB opinionates on various comic-related topics)
The JB Master Checklist
Discount Comic Book Service (New issues by mailorder)
CDisplay (Freeware ECB reader)
The Roger Stern Message Board (featuring participation by JB's good friend, Mr Stern himself!)
Fred Hembeck's Website
The Steve Ditko Playgroup