"Is America Losing Its (Technology) Edge?"

02.01.2011By:Bobby Minnear

A recent Newsweek story, A Case of Senioritis, includes excerpts from Bill Gates speech to the Council of Chief State School Officers. In the speech, Gates states, If theres one thing that can be done for the country, one thingimproving education rises so far above everything else! The story also has some interesting figures: since 1995, the U.S. has fallen from 2nd in the world to 16th in college graduation rates, and it has fallen to 24th place in math (among 15-year-olds).


This got me thinking about what is causing the drop in graduation rates, and what does the decline in academic performance mean for the future of U.S. engineering talent? On a broader scale, I also wonder what this means for the long-term future of the U.S. technology sector, because we need a steady flow of new engineering talent to drive and maintain technology innovation.

Clearly, the cost of a four-year college degree has increased significantly over the last 25 years, and tuition rates continue to rise sharply each year. Beyond college tuition costs, even bigger issues may exist at the K-12 level, where Gates feels that U.S. methods for teacher compensation are outdated and inefficient. Today, pay and promotions for most teachers is based on seniority, rather than performance, peer reviews and other factors. Naturally, Gates is hearing opposition from teacher unions and academic leaders for his views on this topic.

Again, I wonder how these challenges and the way we choose to address them will impact us in regards to our math and engineering talent in the future. When I was working on my masters and PhD programs at Georgia Tech, a large percentage of my fellow students were not American. Are American colleges and universities simply training engineering talent from other countries that will then leave the U.S. upon graduation and return to their home nations to create technology companies of their own? Are we simply exporting top-level engineering skills and talent? How can we make math and science a priority again starting with K-12 to keep tech innovation strong in the U.S.?

I would like to hear what some of the engineering students and academics out there have to say let me know what you think!"



'For God and country - Geronimo, Geronimo, Geronimo.'

Had to post this on this thread.

The problem is that to most Americans the third world still exists in it's 1970s state. They fail to realize or accept (like ostriches) that a country can have low per capita income and still be a technological superpower. Just because we are ahead of say Norway and Japan in say technology X does not necessarily mean we are also ahead of China and India in the same field. It is sad to see so few Americans pursue advanced degrees in the technology fields. All I saw in my graduate program were Chinese, Indians, Koreans and some Eastern Europeans with a handful of Americans. We are well on course to loosing the technology race if 1) the Government keeps cutting funds and 2) Americans do not pursue PhD/M.S. in fields like Math/Engineering/Physics etc.

Here is Bill Gates commenting on this on NPR even before this economic chaos:

Microsoft Chairman Bill Gates predicts that with fewer students in math and science and a lack of national funding, the United States is destined to fall behind other countries in innovation. The fierce competition to keep up with technological changes has led Microsoft to expand research offices in China and India.

http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=4624316

'For God and country - Geronimo, Geronimo, Geronimo.'