I just spoke to the actual woman who makes the yogurt (I spoke to someone at the store who was selling it the first time) and she said it definitely IS pasteurized! I told her I'm pregnant and she promised me that it was and said she couldn't sell it if it wasn't (I kind-of thought that might be the case since my dad bought it in a store, not a farmer's market). So I am at least going to try to act like all is okay... Juliemam- I'm glad I'm not the only one twitching

. Thanks again to both of you for chiming in so quickly!