<< Previous Topic | Next Topic >>Return to Index  

MaterniT21 a bust

July 24 2012 at 3:02 PM
BroodyHen  (no login)

hi everyone.
just posting my update here. i heard back from the genetic counselor that they can't test my blood sample because there is too much maternal DNA in it. they can't separate the fetal DNA so they can't do the test. apparently this is very rare, and doesn't mean anything other than i can't get do the test. i'm incredibly disappointed! i was already wondering if i could live with just the information that the blood test would provide (only testing for the 3 trisomies, not checking all the chromosomes like a CVS or amnio would). now i won't even be able to get that information. i know it is lucky to have this new test in play, just too bad i can't use it sad.gif

they moved my nuchal U/S up to friday (it was scheduled for next week) so i'll have more time to process and decide if i want to do a CVS next week (i'll be 12 wks next week). i don't see changing my mind about the CVS, i just can't risk the pregnancy, and CVS seems to be a much higher risk for immune patients than amnio. i guess we'll wait and see how it goes friday and then contemplate an amnio.

thanks for listening.

 
 Respond to this message   
AuthorReply
Teresa
(no login)

Oh Broody!!!

July 24 2012, 3:47 PM 

I've been waiting for your update!

Oh my gosh. I feel so bad about this because I KNOW ALL too well what that wait is like and to hear this when you have been nervously waiting for results, oh god! How frustrating!

I was peeking in on another board for women who had taken this test while I waited for my results and came across one woman who this happened to as well, same exact thing as you.


http://community.babycenter.com/post/a34784377/couldnt_get_results_xtra_wait

They tested her again. Unfortunately she had to wait the 2 weeks again. I know how grueling that wait is, and I completely understand not wanting to do a CVS or an Amnio. I just couldn't risk it myself.

I think your decision to wait it out and see how your scan goes is the absolute RIGHT thing. Did your GC mention taking another sample at all? Is this something you would consider?

I wish I had more consoling words for you. As you are waiting for your scan and deciding what you'd like to do, try to keep focusing on the 96% that ALL is FINE. I know that's very hard to do, but the odds are very much in your favor. I had to tell myself this many, many times every day I was waiting. I am thinking of you and sending you a BIG hug from across the cyberwaves!








 
 Respond to this message   
Teresa
(no login)

Oh Broody!!!

July 24 2012, 3:47 PM 

I've been waiting for your update!

Oh my gosh. I feel so bad about this because I KNOW ALL too well what that wait is like and to hear this when you have been nervously waiting for results, oh god! How frustrating!

I was peeking in on another board for women who had taken this test while I waited for my results and came across one woman who this happened to as well, same exact thing as you.


http://community.babycenter.com/post/a34784377/couldnt_get_results_xtra_wait

They tested her again. Unfortunately she had to wait the 2 weeks again. I know how grueling that wait is, and I completely understand not wanting to do a CVS or an Amnio. I just couldn't risk it myself.

I think your decision to wait it out and see how your scan goes is the absolute RIGHT thing. Did your GC mention taking another sample at all? Is this something you would consider?

I wish I had more consoling words for you. As you are waiting for your scan and deciding what you'd like to do, try to keep focusing on the 96% that ALL is FINE. I know that's very hard to do, but the odds are very much in your favor. I had to tell myself this many, many times every day I was waiting. I am thinking of you and sending you a BIG hug from across the cyberwaves!








 
 Respond to this message   
Teresa
(no login)

Sorry for the double post, not sure why that happened! n/t

July 24 2012, 3:48 PM 


 
 Respond to this message   
Erin
(no login)

Ugh...

July 24 2012, 4:01 PM 

Broodyhen- I'm so sorry. That must be incredibly frustrating, especially after waiting for the results for the past week or two. Is there any chance there would be more fetal dna and less maternal if they took another blood sample? I think there's a good argument for the company to run it for free if that's the case. I don't have any good advice, but just empathizing with how difficult that must be. As Teresa said, a 96% chance of a good outcome is pretty great. Thinking of you and sending good thoughts...

 
 Respond to this message   
jkl
(no login)

so sorry

July 24 2012, 5:20 PM 


did they stil charge you for the test? I would discuss whether you coud do it again. Could you just get your odds from the nt and go from there? If you have very good odds it may not be worth doing more testing, just depends what your level of comfort is. You should discuss with your genetic counselor how important it is to test all the chromosomes. The 3 tested are the most common (and some of those aren't even very common), so the others would be very rare indeed. The ones incompatible with life may be picked up on the u/s. The amnio also tells you something about spina bifida, another common (non-genetic though) malformation, I don't think cvs does. So all the tests have their pros and cons. Good luck with the nuchal. jkl

 
 Respond to this message   
mel
(no login)

Ugh, indeed!

July 24 2012, 7:55 PM 

So sorry! How frustrating!

Thankfully you are able to get in this week for your NT scan. Hopefully that will give you some solace and also give you information you may need in moving forward with your decision to go for further testing or not.

These decisions are not easy to make and the waiting for testing (and then results) becomes frustrating and anxiety ridden. Here's hoping the NT scan on Friday goes well and is able to help you in your decision making process.

Sending lots of good thoughts your way!

 
 Respond to this message   
Sara H
(no login)

Uggg, so frustrating!

July 25 2012, 9:09 AM 

I am so sorry!

Can they test again and put a "rush" on it? (I am not totally clear on the science of this one so I don't know if that is even possible.)

Good luck and I am so sorry!
Sara H

 
 Respond to this message   
BroodyHen
(no login)

i really appreciate

July 26 2012, 1:56 AM 

all of your thoughtful, supportive replies. so, the full story is -- i insisted (even though the GC and perinatal office thought it was INSANE) on having two tests. there are actually two companies (more, actually) that do the blood test, and my thinking was that if the labs were different or they used slightly different techniques it could be meaningful to run the test twice, especially for trisomy 13 and 18 which have a much lower accuracy rate. they agreed, and the first result is actually from Verify (the brand name of the test. my perinatal office switched from materniT21 to verify because they were first to add trisomy 13 and 18 testing). i am still waiting for the MaterniT21 results, though the GC is pretty certain it will be the same result - unable to test the sample. interesting that i haven't heard yet, maybe they can read the sample?! and very interesting link you posted, teresa, thanks so much!, it does look like materniT21 has a fair number of false positives, and that maybe when samples are inconclusive they simply call it a positive? hard to figure all that out from the baby center posts, but it is concerning. i'm so glad i read about that before getting the materniT21 result in case it is positive, so i know to follow up on how exactly they made the diagnosis.

my GC and the GCs at verify don't think there is going to be any change in a new sample taken at a different time, they are not recommending retesting, but are willing to try if i want to. they haven't yet told me whether i am being charged for the test with no result or if they'll rerun the test at no additional charge. i am inclined to try again just in case there is a change, but i also worry about accuracy of the results if my blood is wonky (it is wonky, presumably due to the clotting disorder). they suspect it might be the clotting disorder/autoimmune disease and/or lovenox skewing things, but they really don't know. blah, blah, blah.

so, i'm going in for the nuchal on friday. i will get new odds and more info and will see where we are. hopefully it will become clear what, if anything, to do next....

thanks so much again for the support.

 
 Respond to this message   
Teresa
(no login)

Re: i really appreciate

July 26 2012, 6:48 AM 

Broody I read your post several times, I'm confused. The MaterniT21 test also tests for the Trisomys. The MaterniT21 test has a 99.1% detection rate for DS, a 99.9% detection rate for Trisomy 18 and 91.7% detection rate for Trisomy 13. I'm not sure about Verify. So, the test you took then was Verify, not MaterniT21?

I hope you don't have to be charged twice for that test! And I hope you get more answers from your Nuchal. I really think the Nuchal is a great indicator, especially for us who are AMA, more so than the blood tests.

Keep us posted.

 
 Respond to this message   
BroodyHen
(no login)

clarification

July 26 2012, 11:20 AM 

sorry, i know it is confusing and i've jumbled to story.

my peri uses the verify test. yes, both materniT21 and veryify now test for trisomy 13 and 18, but verify was the first to do it and my peri's office switched to the verify test some time ago. so when i went in for my genetic counseling, they told me i could get the verify test. since the detection rate for trisomy 13 and 18 is lower, i wanted to get BOTH the verify and the materniT21 test, which they allowed (though i had to pay $235 out of pocket for the materniT21 test, since verify is their standard and billed to insurance). the result that came in first was from verify - they can't test the sample because of too much maternal DNA. still waiting to hear from materniT21. my GC says the companies use the same technology and should get the same result. the sample for both tests was given at the same time.

if materniT21 is also unable to read the sample, i think i will try again, though i've been advised not to expect a different result. i will find out about charges tomorrow when i go in for the nuchal.

i know it doesn't really make sense why i wanted to test with two companies, but i just figured that with about a 92% detection rate for 13 and 18 there would be a better chance of catching a problem if the test were run by two different labs. considering what is happening, i'm glad i did. if both companies find they can't actually test my sample, then i won't worry that all this is lab error or sample contamination. anyway, i'll post tomorrow after the nuchal...

thanks!

 
 Respond to this message   
Teresa
(no login)

got it!

July 26 2012, 1:57 PM 

I understand now. Makes sense now (sorry about that)
I hope you get something back from the MaterniT21 test, it will be interesting to see if the results are the same or not.
I hope your nuchal goes great, though I am sure it will. Knowing I had a good measurement took away a bit of the stress for me because it is important. Looking forward to your update.

 
 Respond to this message   
Marti
(Login longing4baby)

Positive Thoughts for today

July 27 2012, 7:19 AM 

Hi BroodyHen,
Receiving the news about the blood tests must have been disappointing but I am still holding out good thoughts for all the blood work. I know your scan is today and wanted to send you positive thoughts and warm wishes. Take care!

 
 Respond to this message   
BroodyHen
(no login)

thanks for thinking of me, marti :) n/t

July 28 2012, 12:33 AM 


 
 Respond to this message   
Current Topic - MaterniT21 a bust
  << Previous Topic | Next Topic >>Return to Index