You keep on affirming that Bix had a breakdown in Cleveland a few days before Ray Miller recorded "Cradle of Love." I posted on numerous occasions a discussion of the available documentation regarding Bix's reported breakdowns in Cleveland. As I demonstrated, but you don't seem to accept, there are only two documented facts.
- Bix had a breakdown on Nov 30, 1928 in Cleveland.
- Bix did not play with Paul Whiteman's orchestra at the concert at the Palace Theatre on Jan 20, 1929
The rest is conjecture, educated guesses. Do you know of any incontrovertible documentation that places Bix in Cleveland on Jan 20, 1929? If you disagree with my analyses, please provide a critique of my evaluation of the available information summarized in several of my postings.
Maybe the juxtaposition of the three solos is unconvincing to you. As ar as I am concerned, it is quite convincing.
Unfortunatley, there is no definitive solution to this problem. It is a matter of what I described several times as "Bix is in the ear of the beholder."