<< Previous Topic | Next Topic >>  

Pre-ww2 Yorkshire Vs post-ww2 Yorkshire

October 22 2017 at 3:07 PM
Gavin Gray  (Login yorkie1863)

 
Who would you pick to be in each team. Players like Len Hutton who played before and after the war can only appear in one team.

My teams are;

Pre-ww2; Sutcliffe, Holmes, Hutton, Leyland, Mitchell, Rhodes (c), Hunter (D)(w), Hirst, Verity, Macaulay, Bowes.
Post-ww2; Boycott (c), Root, Lehman (D), Bairstow (J), Ballance, Blakey(w), Trueman, Gough, Old, Wardle, Hoggard.

 
 Respond to this message   
AuthorReply
Seadog73
(Login Seadog73)

Re: Pre-ww2 Yorkshire Vs post-ww2 Yorkshire

October 22 2017, 3:46 PM 

Post WW2 - give Bairstow the gloves and put Close in for Blakey. I'd also put Ryan in for either Old or Hoggard for left arm variety.

Classic winter thread by the way!


    
This message has been edited by Seadog73 on Oct 22, 2017 3:48 PM


 
 
Gavin Gray
(Login yorkie1863)

Re: Pre-ww2 Yorkshire Vs post-ww2 Yorkshire

October 22 2017, 4:02 PM 

Sorry but Blakey in my opinion is a way better keeper. I could be persuaded re Ryan.

 
 
Stu
(Login StuartRA)
Assistant Moderator

Re: Pre-ww2 Yorkshire Vs post-ww2 Yorkshire

October 22 2017, 4:15 PM 

Close, Illingworth & Siddy in for Gough, Old & Wardle in the Post-ww2, for me. This is based on performances for Yorkshire as opposed to England performances. Gough is a NPFY member.

 
 
Idle man
(Login Idle_man)

Re: Pre-ww2 Yorkshire Vs post-ww2 Yorkshire

October 22 2017, 4:30 PM 

Vaughan ahead of Ballance. Siddy is a must, possibly the second best opening bowler we've had.

Now wicket-keeping. You either want an all-rounder, in which case it's Jonny Bairstow, who is far better with the bat than any other contender, or you want a specialist, in which case it's Jimmy Binks by a country mile.

 
 
Guest
(Login ThirdUmpire)

Re: Pre-ww2 Yorkshire Vs post-ww2 Yorkshire

October 22 2017, 6:15 PM 

It's surely a game where your keeper doesn't need to be competent with a bat so pick the best keeper which is Binks by a mile

Boycott
Root
Lehmann
Close
Bairstow J
Bresnan or Old or Rashid depending on the track etc
Illingworth
Trueman
Sidebottom
Binks
Hoggard

 
 
marsker
(Login marskeman)

Re: Pre-ww2 Yorkshire Vs post-ww2 Yorkshire

October 22 2017, 8:25 PM 

no way would Boycott captain my team. he was an awful captain. Brian Close every time, and then Raymond Illingworth.

 
 
Idle man
(Login Idle_man)

Re: Pre-ww2 Yorkshire Vs post-ww2 Yorkshire

October 22 2017, 9:01 PM 

Agree re Boycott captaincy. In any case if he was captain half the others suggested would make themselves unavailable.

There’s a name often overlooked when we have this sort of discussion. It’s Bob Appleyard. Before my time, but one, probably biased, commentator said he was a combination of Bedser and Laker, which sounds distinctly above average.

 
 
Guest
(Login Irving08)

Re: Pre-ww2 Yorkshire Vs post-ww2 Yorkshire

October 22 2017, 10:32 PM 

Illlingworth and Sidebottom instead of Blakey and Gough. Bairstow J can keep wicket; Illy as captain supreme as well as a very capable batsman and economical spinner.


 
 

Dave Morton
(Login DaveMorton)

Re: Pre-ww2 Yorkshire Vs post-ww2 Yorkshire

October 23 2017, 12:48 AM 

Binks to keep wicket every time, not even worth discussing, as good a keeper as Trueman was a bowler or Root a batsman. And I can't believe nobody has got Craig White in.

Post-war 13: Boycott, McGrath, Root, Lehmann, Close, Bairstow J, White, Illingworth, Wardle, Trueman, Binks, Hoggard, Sidebottom.

And that's leaving out: Watson, Appleyard, Nicholson, Moxon, Old, Athey, Vaughan, Gough, Silverwood, Lyth and Ballance.

Willie Watson was used by England as an opener, so there's a case to be made for him as Boycott's partner...but you could just pick any of these in your XI. Greatness everywhere.

 
 
Tyke1950
(Login Tyke1950)

Re: Pre-ww2 Yorkshire Vs post-ww2 Yorkshire

October 23 2017, 8:07 AM 

I agree with Dave's evaluation of Binks completely and would have him in the post-war side. I never had the good fortune to see Wardle play but would certainly defer to Dave on that selection. Most of my elders speak of him as a true great.
I part Company with him on Boycott's opening partner. To prefer McGrath over Vaughan seems perverse. The issue of a third seamer to complement Trueman and Sidebottom is less clear cut. Hoggard is an excellent choice. My own preference would be for Chris Old.
For me: Dave's team; with Vaughan for McGrath and Old for Hoggard.

 
 

Dave Morton
(Login DaveMorton)

Re: Pre-ww2 Yorkshire Vs post-ww2 Yorkshire

October 23 2017, 10:37 AM 

I can't believe I forgot Phil Sharpe. So many good players to choose from! But he was just the best slip-catcher of all time; his batting would be about on a par with McGrath, Vaughan, Moxon, etc, so he would be another opening option, the only position where there is not a wealth of talent.

I always preferred the solidity of McGrath to Vaughan's more exotic strokeplay. Mags was a superb player of really fast bowling and was unlucky to have a dip in form in his early 20s, just as Vaughan was kicking on towards the England team.

To try to prove my point, I once took the trouble to compare figures of the two of them IN MATCHES IN WHICH BOTH PLAYED. Actually, there wasn't much in it, with Mags winning but only by a fraction of a run per innings. Mags was much the better fieldsman, though. Try not to remember him as the fat man who went on a season too long. Players deserve to be remembered for their best years.


    
This message has been edited by DaveMorton on Oct 23, 2017 10:49 AM


 
 
Anthony Rowe
(Login tonyinsiam)

Post ww2

October 23 2017, 11:44 AM 

Yes, very interesting topic- could, and should, go on all winter.
So many outstanding players that I think we could pick 2 or 3, more or less, equal teams-especially post war. For me, one absolutely outstanding player was, as Idle Man said earlier, Bob Appleyard MBE. He had a short career but managed 208 wickets in one season and many Aussies said he was the best bowler they had seen from these shores. That was in Hutton's Ashes success in the 50's.
His book-"No Coward Soul"- written with the help of Stephen Chalke- Published 2008- is still available on Amazon and is a brilliant read.

 
 

Dave Morton
(Login DaveMorton)

Re: Pre-ww2 Yorkshire Vs post-ww2 Yorkshire

October 23 2017, 12:54 PM 

I saw relatively little of Bob Aoppleyard. In any case I was too young to appreciate him in his breakthrough season. But I met an old guy, Sussex or Somerset, who insisted Appleyard was the best of the lot, a truly great bowler.

The pre-war generation venerated Hedley Verity, perhaps the greatest spin bowler of all time, and a man much loved and respected for his integrity and general bearing and conduct - something Appleyard and Wardle never aspired to, if the stories are true.

In my Cambridge University days (early 60s) I played against people who had met Wardle in Minor Counties cricket - he played for Nelson Saturdays and Cambridgeshire mid-week, following his sacking by Yorkshire. These guys were in awe of his talent, but scared stiff of his lashing tongue. He thought nothing of publicly humiliating teammates, especially those who dropped catches off his bowling.

 
 
JollyD
(Login JollyD)

Pre ww 2 Yorkshire vs post ww2 Yorkshire

October 23 2017, 3:57 PM 

I see that there is no debate so far about the pre ww2 team. Presumably this is because you would need to be well turned 90 to have any meaningful memory of their comparable abilities. We rely instead on contemporary written and oral accounts.
Even post war players in their pomp in the 40's and 50's are hazy to many of us.
Certain questions come to mind which would influence selection.
Would the games be played over 3 or 4 days ?
Would the pitches be covered or uncovered ? This would determine the extent of the involvement of attacking spin bowlers, and the quality of 'keeper required.
Which no ball rule would be invoked - front or back foot ? This might make a difference to the selection of quick bowlers.
Which LBW rule would operate ? Some batsmen would have difficulty with the old rule.
Do we permit helmets ? If not, courage would become as important as technique.

If we are not comparing like with like, selection becomes haphazard and increasingly subjective.

 
 
Tyke1950
(Login Tyke1950)

Re: Pre-ww2 Yorkshire Vs post-ww2 Yorkshire

October 23 2017, 4:06 PM 

We've focussed on finessing the post-war team. Perhaps there's scope to concentrate on their opponents.
None of us, I think, are in a position to judge them on much other than statistics and eye-witness accounts.
It occurs to me, however, that Gavin's team is very heavily weighted towards the inter-war years.
I feel sure a few sprightly 130 year olds might want to sing the praises of FS Jackson (surely a shoe-in to replace Ticker Mitchell at five) or Bobby Peel. Perhaps they'd want to refer us to the views their parents held about 'Silver Billy' Bates or Tom Emmett.

I wish we had a time-machine that would enable us to judge some of the golden-age greats who played on wickets flattened by horse-drawn rollers and who wore cane pads and flimsy gloves and used raw meat to protect their palms if they stood behind the wicket.
I feel sure that some of them, at least, would deserve to represent the pre-war eleven and do it proud.

 
 
Tyke1950
(Login Tyke1950)

Re: Pre-ww2 Yorkshire Vs post-ww2 Yorkshire

October 23 2017, 4:08 PM 

I see Jolly D and I have been musing on similar things almost simultaneously!

 
 
Tyke1950
(Login Tyke1950)

Re: Pre-ww2 Yorkshire Vs post-ww2 Yorkshire

October 23 2017, 4:08 PM 

I see Jolly D and I have been musing on similar things almost simultaneously!

 
 
Guest
(Login ThirdUmpire)

Re: Pre-ww2 Yorkshire Vs post-ww2 Yorkshire

October 23 2017, 6:33 PM 

Ok pre war team.

I'm not sure about Hutton at 3. I'd omit Holmes and let Len open with Herbert.

This then leaves room to pick Lord Hawke who would be needed to manage the other 10 and ensure a few of them got a bowl otherwise Verity and Bowes may never get the ball from Kirkheatons double act.

Wasn't Hunter like Binks and basically a great keeper who batted 11?

It's a tad unfair that we allow the post war team to have an overseas player but not the pre war side although I suspect only Bradman is good enough to merit consideration. Perhaps Hawke being born in Lincolshire should class as the outsider?

And I'd pick Peel ahead of Macaulay just for the added entertainment factor.

 
 
Brian
(Login NewBrian)

Re: Pre-ww2 Yorkshire Vs post-ww2 Yorkshire

October 24 2017, 3:51 PM 

One fairly strong candidate for the post-war side, surely - G St A Sobers, given that we managed to sneak him in in 1964, although I'd hate to see Boof miss out

https://www.theguardian.com/sport/the-nightwatchman/2015/sep/17/yorkshire-beatlemania-crack-america-1964-cricket-brian-close

ps would like this thread to last through Christmas


    
This message has been edited by NewBrian on Oct 24, 2017 3:52 PM


 
 
 
< Previous Page 1 2 3 4 Next >
  Respond to this message   
  << Previous Topic | Next Topic >>  
 Copyright © 1999-2017 Network54. All rights reserved.   Terms of Use   Privacy Statement  
All IP addresses are recorded. We reserve the right to remove personal attacks, sexist, racist, homophobic, defamatory or abusive comments, comments likely to incite religious hatred, those disposed to wind others up, and unapproved advertising.

Email us: Whiterosecricket@hotmail.co.uk