<< Previous Topic | Next Topic >>Return to Index  

Two men per 1 gun? Proof to this?

June 20 2006 at 7:28 PM

Codala  (Login Codala)
Panzer Brigade(Germany)

I have a question...when I tend to talk to people about ww2 and the German invasion of Russia, is it actually true or anything proof that some russian soldiers were limited 1 gun per two men? Any clarification would help, thanks

 
 Respond to this message   
AuthorReply

Eric
(Login Nighthawk00)
Eagle Squadron(US)

Re: Two men per 1 gun? Proof to this?

June 20 2006, 11:03 PM 

I even heard that in Stalingrad it was 1 gun for 4 men !


Don't try this at home lads
"The enemy dies relaxed," observed a Lockheed Martin manager.

 
 

Big Fat Panda Bear
(Login BigFatPandaBear)
GROUP LEADER

Re: Two men per 1 gun? Proof to this?

June 21 2006, 3:37 AM 

Saw the movie "Enemy at the Gates", the main character (Jude law) was given a clip of bullets and no rifle. He was told to wait for guys with rifles to get kill and then pick up a weapon. LOL

-------------------------------------------------
Stocky Returns ... after every Punch!

 
 

Codala
(Login Codala)
Panzer Brigade(Germany)

Re: Two men per 1 gun? Proof to this?

June 21 2006, 4:20 AM 

Thing is I need visible proof, not from just movies, but if you guys have any that would help

 
 


(Login FE3T)
EXPERT POSTER

Re: Two men per 1 gun? Proof to this?

June 21 2006, 6:43 AM 

Visible proof might be hard to find. Just find recollections of Stalingrad veterans (I believe there were 460 that made it out of the original 10,000) and check that.



Hosted by Putfile.com Hosted by Putfile.com



~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
"When you go home tell them of us, and say, for your tomorrow, we gave our today."
- Kohima Memorial
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
'Guru Nanak, the founder of the religion, preached oneness of God and brotherhood of man. At that time Hinduism and Islam were the predominant religions in India; and relations between the two communities were not good. Guru Nanak preached dignity of man and tolerance for the viewpoint of others: "The World is burning, O Lord, Save it, O Save it, by whichever door it pleases thee."
- Guru Granth


    
This message has been edited by FE3T on Jun 21, 2006 6:43 AM


 
 

Rusland
(Login FEofRus)
Mother Russia

Re: Two men per 1 gun? Proof to this?

June 21 2006, 7:06 AM 

Codala,that is bs
Dont take it seriously..Russians lost a lot during 41-42 but "1 gun for 4 men " ? Some partisans maybe (or the other cases such as Vjazma 42)

 
 

Codala
(Login Codala)
Panzer Brigade(Germany)

Re: Two men per 1 gun? Proof to this?

June 21 2006, 12:51 PM 

Hah..okay thank you, but what about ANY gun to men ratio being a bit off? Any links to them at all? Much appreciated

 
 
Anonymous
(Login phifflon)
RedCoats(UK)

Re: Two men per 1 gun? Proof to this?

June 21 2006, 11:24 PM 

It was not true at the start but the USSR lost so many wepons in the first few weeks they could not make replacements fast enough.

See Stalingrad by Antony Beevor

Wepons facory were moved on mass to beyond the Uriels which mad matters worse.
Post 1942 there were enogh wepons for all.
Saying that If the USSR transport sytem woked better more wepons could have reached the 62nd army

 
 

GoItaly
(Login GoItaly)
Member

Re: Two men per 1 gun? Proof to this?

June 22 2006, 11:34 PM 

Can anyone recommend a good book on Stalingrad?

-----------------------------

 
 
Current Topic - Two men per 1 gun? Proof to this?  Respond to this message   
  << Previous Topic | Next Topic >>Return to Index