ID has no mechanism of how an ID created, let alone what an ID is.
ID is like taking a magic wand, tapping three times, and saying Abracadabra and presto it was created.
Evolution on the other hand is defined as the change in allele frequency of populations over time. Mechanisms include mutation, natural selection, genetic drift, etc..
So evolution wins easily. We know what it is and have working mechanisms on how it occurs.
ID can be anything. God? What is a god? How would we know a god if we came across one? What are the distinguising characteristics of a god? Furthermore, how did "god" create?