Micah, I feel the same way as you do about the 372. I wear it more often than my other PAMs, including my first, my beloved 249. My 217 and 26K almost never see the light of day. The 368 and Brownie get little wrist time too.
It seems that the 372 captures what I want to see in a PAM, and fulfills the role of a PAM if that makes any sense. I don't wear my PAMs with suits, for example. When I'm dressed casually, and think a PAM goes well with what I'm wearing, the 372 will always fit right in.
That said, you have some incredibly cool pieces there, particularly the 232, 249 and the 360 of course. So, I like the idea of hiding them in a safe or something for a few months and then rediscovering them close up. You may fall in love all over again. If you're still into the 372 as you are now, then you know you can sell them.
Whatever you decide, I know you will make the right call for you.