It was said they were all drunk, and she was terrified of dark water, didnt like going near it, but if she was drunk, she could have. But for some reasom, I thing Robert had something to do with it... one will never know what happened on that boat

I beg to differ. We know most everything that happened on that boat that night. We know Wagner was with her when she left the boat, too. I think we pretty much know everything, except for what spot of the boat she was forced into the water from.

We know who is we?

Drunk SCHMUNCK: I've been socially drunk many times in my life: drinking the way the Wagner party drank that night. Being drunk fueled the emotions, possibly the actions and reactions, but it certainly is no excuse for what happened, and it certainly doesn't erase their memories of anything to do with that night. Death is a fairly good reason to try to remember all one can. That's why it was crucial that those men be interrogated immediately. Horrible handling of this case. Simply horrible.

Strange how I see new names here and this thread would be enhancing the conversation on the Premeditated thread instead of standing alone. Why start a new one when it all goes hand in hand?
Strange, very strange indeed.

All three men should have remained on the island, should have been interrogated, should have been checked for marks. Wagner was given celebrity privilege that the rest of us would not have been allowed.
I'm sure RJ remembers everything that happened that horrible night, I'm sure he remembers just as well as Davern does.

I'm not new, I'm just using my initials because we agreed to not post anonymously. I think this thread was started by the troll. Look at the spelling in the original post. And the ignorance is strong. I say, let's go back to the premed thread. Leave this one to the OP.

I dont see anything wrong with this tread. Why are we even discussing the validity of a thread?

I think we should ignore anyone anonymous and I think we should go back to the premeditated thread previously suggested.
Oh, Paytn, I'm with you all the way on your thoughts. All three men should have never been allowed to leave the island until a full investigation was completed.

BK, last time I checked it was still a live free country and until the moderator makes his decision, post whatever you want. The login Grayhair seems to do just that but anyone who has read her attacks of the GNGS book on book seller sites can see where she is coming from with her posts. It sure sounds like a personal thing to me and if the owner of the Network I belong to puts it all together she will probably throw me off too like she threw other innocent people off but no worry. On her site if you trash Natalie or Natalie's side of the family it is OK but don't trash RJ or out you go.