Buy/Sell/Trade Area Home Collector Links

Vintage Hockey Collectors Price Guide

  << Previous Topic | Next Topic >>Return to Index  

Great deal on eBay?

October 24 2007 at 12:20 AM
  (Login mapnwpa)

Anyone want a PSA 4 1933 Morenz Goudey Sport Kings card for $325.00? This card has been on eBay for almost 13 days, Buy It Now, seller has 99.7% positive feedback. I have no interest in the card, as I only collect goalies. I just thought this is a great deal. If someone picks it up, let us know.

eBay item #110179664092

PS I assume I am not violating the rules, as this item is Buy It Now and has been around for awhile.

 
 Respond to this message   
AuthorReply

Anonymous
(Login James_McThigh)

Re: Great deal on eBay?

October 24 2007, 2:12 PM 

The card has been up for 13 days and no one has yet purchased it. So how can it be a good deal?

Stop spamming.


    
This message has been edited by James_McThigh on Oct 24, 2007 2:13 PM


 
 

(Login mapnwpa)

reply

October 24 2007, 4:56 PM 

First of all, I am not "spamming". I have NO personal interest in this card. I do, however, like the idea of helping fellow collectors to spot the occasional bargsin on eBay. I have personally seen a few great cards available at a low price on eBay in the Buy it Now section. I actually pointed someone in this forum to a 1933 OPC Morenz card that was a great buy. If you feel it is not a good buy, OK. Do you have any facts to back up your view, other than the card not selling yet? What do PSA 4 Sport King Morenz cards go for?

 
 

Anonymous
(Login James_McThigh)

Re: Great deal on eBay?

October 24 2007, 7:09 PM 

Here are the last seven sales of this card in PSA 4 according to www.vintagecardprices.com:

1) $137.70
2) $272.77
3) $252.49
4) $167.50
5) $252.49
6) $257.99
7) $293.98

So if you get this card for under $200, then that is a steal. $325 is too much.
Thanks

 
 
George Dreher
(Login historicalcards)

bargain?

October 24 2007, 10:28 PM 

I picked up a PSA-4 Morenz in August for $125 at a show. The OP must be getting high on his own supply?

 
 

(Login mapnwpa)

unwarranted personal attacks

October 25 2007, 8:58 AM 

"Gentlemen":

There is no need for personal attacks in this forum. I have never done drugs (can you say the same?), nor have I spammed anyone. Why can't we have a simple discussion without attacks??????????????????????? I agree that a vintage card is worth what people will pay for it. I will admit that I was wrong, the card is not a deal at $325, fine. Why did I think it was? Beckett lists the card at 500 in VG condition and Charlton lists it at 600. YES, I know these can be way off. A recent eBay auction for an ungraded Morenz Sport Kings card went for $381, and that card is not a PSA 4. Could this auction have been an aberation? Sure.

Anyway, I propose that, in the future, if I see a Buy It Now card I think is a bargain, I will list it under the Cards for Sale section, where you can ignore it. Is that acceptable, and can you respond to this without a personal attack on me???????

 
 

Andrew
(Login Hockeyguy_49911)

Re: Great deal on eBay?

October 25 2007, 9:59 AM 

David I think what you did was fine and if I was going after a card like that and missed it I would be very happy with you. So please keep me in mind if you spot any deals on C56 cards in PSA 3-4 grade, haha.

 
 
Earl Strohmeyer
(Login strohman)

Buy It Now Deals

October 27 2007, 11:26 PM 

Andrew,

I would be surprised if YOU missed a deal on a nice C56 card! You have an Eagle Eye for those cards on eBay!


 
 
Current Topic - Great deal on eBay?  Respond to this message   
  << Previous Topic | Next Topic >>Return to Index