<< Previous Topic | Next Topic >>Return to Index  

Beliveau Rookie card graded 9.5 by KSA

October 20 2008 at 9:07 PM

  (Login GillesRen)


 
 Respond to this message   
AuthorReply

Donald
(Login danthevintageman)

Re: Beliveau Rookie card graded 9.5 by KSA

October 20 2008, 10:20 PM 

that card is a rookie reprint from a 1990's parkhurst insert set.
read the label.LOL boy there are some real suckers still on ebay. over $100 for a 1992-93 insert,the guy must have thought he got a great deal. LOL

 
 

(Login shiftintermedia)

Re: Beliveau Rookie card graded 9.5 by KSA

October 20 2008, 10:44 PM 

wow! The prices people pay for utter trash.
That thing is not worth the grading fee.

People need to be more informed on these things... Either that or they don't care.
I remember a few weeks ago a "reprint"Orr RC that sold for $1100.00!

 
 
Joe
(Login JOE-1)

Re: Beliveau Rookie card graded 9.5 by KSA

October 20 2008, 11:40 PM 

Seller is a REAL DOG !!! ....

****Rather misleading title if you ask me *****
Item was listed as a 1953-54 Parkie Jean Beliveau RP Rookie KSA 9.5
when it should have been listed as a 92-93 Parkie Beliveau. Not to mention it was listed under the pre 1980 category.

He's got a 92-93 OPC Patrick Roy Rookie Anniversary Card
listed as a 1986-87 OPC Rookie as well...........

Both items violate ebays TOS rules (under misleading deceptive titles) Seller knew exactly what he was doing.

I'm pretty sure the buyer got fooled, and just read the title ~ it's pretty easy to miss the "RP" in the title when cruising the pre 1980 categories ~ especially if you've had a couple of pops under the belt.

I smell a paypal claim and/or a well deserved negative coming.

 
 
Joe
(Login JOE-1)

Re: Beliveau Rookie card graded 9.5 by KSA

October 20 2008, 11:47 PM 

All cards are guaranteed to be original! 100% Money Back Guarantee!**

YUP ... original reprint.

Free Smiley Face Courtesy of www.FreeSmileys.org

 
 


(Login Hockeyguy_49911)

Re: Beliveau Rookie card graded 9.5 by KSA

October 21 2008, 11:23 AM 

Joe it is misleading BUT anyone willing to pay $100+ on a card should know what RP means, Also in the description of the card inside the auction it says REPRINT in big letters, and lastly on the scan it says Rookie Reprint on the label. This buyer had 3 chances, 3 strikes and now hes out of money.

 
 
Joe
(Login JOE-1)

Re: Beliveau Rookie card graded 9.5 by KSA

October 21 2008, 12:52 PM 

Andrew .... TOTALLY AGREE, the buyer assumes the responsibility of knowing what he's buying .......

It's just that in this day and age, where time is money (and i've done it myself) you BID and read the fine print later. Unfortunately sometimes the fine print later part ~~~ comes after the auction has ended.

Sellers know this ...... and hope to catch someone sleeping at the wheel, otherwise why the deception??

Check out the dudes last negative, obviously he's learned nothing!!

 
 

Gilles
(Login GillesRen)

Re: Beliveau Rookie card graded 9.5 by KSA

October 21 2008, 1:58 PM 

Even I, got caught!

I just noticed it was written as reprint.
And it was clearly written: Reprint Rookie 1992-93.

But by looking at the card, its margins and the grade, I came to the conclusion it was not an original.


 
 


(Login Hockeyguy_49911)

Re: Beliveau Rookie card graded 9.5 by KSA

October 21 2008, 9:44 PM 

Joe, you are right, no need for a seller to trick a quick looker like that. I wonder what that negative was for (which card?).

 
 
Elmar
(Login esb1922)

Re: Beliveau Rookie card graded 9.5 by KSA

October 22 2008, 3:16 PM 

Andrew,

yes, the buyer assumes the responsibility ... but in this particular case the buyer is French Canadian with poor English and could easily misunderstand the "RP" thing, so I would rather help than laugh at him.


 
 


(Login Hockeyguy_49911)

Re: Beliveau Rookie card graded 9.5 by KSA

October 22 2008, 4:42 PM 

Elmar,

I was never laughing at him. I have lost money a couple times on reprint cards.

Andrew

 
 
Elmar
(Login esb1922)

Re: Beliveau Rookie card graded 9.5 by KSA

October 22 2008, 5:56 PM 

Andrew, when I said "laugh" I was not referring to you or to anybody else in particular.

By the way, I spoke to him and he admitted that he didn't read carefully the card's description, so I told him what Joe suggested, to claim money back because of misleading description.

 
 
Anonymous
(Login frozencaribou)

If you were interested in the Beliveau, how about a Gretzky?

October 24 2008, 9:28 PM 

http://cgi.ebay.ca/1979-OPC-O-PEE-CHEE-WAYNE-GRETZKY-SIGNED-PSA-DNA-SLAB_W0QQitemZ200267421838QQihZ010QQcategoryZ213QQssPageNameZWDVWQQrdZ1QQcmdZViewItem

Honestly, sometimes I don't know what to think of how this "hobby" has evolved. By the way, the truth in the auction above resides in the LOA, not in the PSA holder. Notice how the Gretzky signature conveniently goes right over the place where the printers mark should be?

 
 

Gilles
(Login GillesRen)

Re: Beliveau Rookie card graded 9.5 by KSA

October 24 2008, 9:47 PM 

"Notice how the Gretzky signature conveniently goes right over the place where the printers mark should be?"

Is there an issue with the printer mark since it's a reprint?

 
 

(Login frozencaribou)

Re: Beliveau Rookie card graded 9.5 by KSA

October 24 2008, 9:58 PM 

No, it's just that the card is not labeled as a reprint by the "PSA holder" and one of the telltale signs of a Gretzky fake is the lack of a print dot on his left shoulder. I think the photo and the text lead people to believe the card is authentic and it isn't, as per the fine print of the LOA.

Just another example of buyer beware.

 
 
Current Topic - Beliveau Rookie card graded 9.5 by KSA  Respond to this message   
  << Previous Topic | Next Topic >>Return to Index