I think Pikes Peak is over-rated. I've been there twice.
I think Mount Evans is a better, less commercial or crowded experience, with superior views too.
That's without factoring in Mount Evans being higher too.
Yeah, Pikes can be a bit frustrating dealing with tourists on the summit, but I don't think you'll find it overrated if you dayhike Barr Trail. For a true mountaineering experience, try the Y couloir on the north face. There's a remote, rugged personality to the mountain on that side.