As the opening post of this thread tells usAugust 10 2008 at 9:39 AM
|JVH (no login)|
Response to There are atheists fighting in Iraq
... the topic is: "what makes a Christian?" - the topic is not "what makes an atheist?"
As for God deciding: any assertion involving the biblical God proposition is a case of reification; hypostatization, which in effect acknowledges the proposition cannot stand on its own, rendering the assertion invalid.
Unless, of course, I am wrong and you can show so be refuting the argument.