CHRIS CRAFT COMMANDER FORUM ® .......A photo-intensive technical reference file and ongoing newsletter regarding the original fiberglass Chris-Craft Commander series. This is an independent not-for-profit and non-commercial web site, not affiliated with the Chris Craft Commander Club ~~ or ~~ Chris-Craft Corporation. Our mission here is to "have fun and share information" about the Commander series (and those associated fiberglass boats on the Chris-Craft family tree) for your individual personal use, and by doing so help promote the good name of Chris-Craft, and help preserve, restore, and appreciate Chris-Craft boats. The main reference feature is the ever expanding MASTER INDEX File which contains what we believe to be the world's largest collection of documentation photos and technical information on the Chris-Craft Commander line of boats, (like these original brochure scans, featuring the iconic first 38 Commander styled by Fred Hudson, and many of the great Dick Avery renditions that followed) , (a huge collection of Chris-Craft 427 tuning and specification information), and a few words about how to use the forum.

We extend to you a cordial "WELCOME ABOARD !" Come on in, make yourself at home, we are a friendly group of enthusiasts, and we also appreciate the classic Chris Craft Roamer, Corsair, and Lancer boats too , as they are all on the same family tree and share much in common ! Just start by posting a note introducing yourself to the group, that's all it takes here (we don't ask for or retain any personal information here, because our intention is to just "have fun and share information".

This forum is registered as chriscraftcommander.com

   

Agree, not so simple

December 27 2017 at 7:17 PM
Pierre  (Login cayuco)


Response to Full vs block only

Henry, I'm glad you chimed in to this topic. It has been on my list for some time and I am still not comfortable as to the best approach.
I have studied the cooling diagrams and I see substantial differences between the closed cooling (CC) and raw water (RW) systems.

vE-0ac2o8gS_qgjr7fIXeRa0h-FkNMYjACB9RncWoa61u1oiK_YO2OSvPGyFI80Kq6yNueXKJjRUfGNzpMmdjtsrw4zSqW_L6cOXnqYLdJLegz6ScaCVmZk5Y8vd5Sd_ims1mJo-JA

For starts, the thermostats are on opposite sides of the engine. In the RW system: water comes in, splits into the feed to the PRVs on the risers and the rest is immediately redirected to the logs by the recirculating pump and after the logs goes into the block.

By contrast, the CC system takes water in, goes to PRVs, to the heat exchanger, the thermostat, the engine block, and finally to the logs at the end of the cycle. Not an insignificant difference between the two systems.

So if one adds a heat exchanger, where should it go? before the cycle as in the CC system? After the cycle as in RW? Does it matter? Should the thermostat be relocated front to back? Can a Chris Craft Closed Cooling thermostat housing be sourced at reasonable cost?
The Chris Craft heat exchanger has one port in and six out. I have not seen an aftermarket heat exchanger with that configuration, if one where to try to replicate the Chris Craft closed cooling.

I have spoken with suppliers of "cooling kits" and got very tentative "wishy-washy" responses. My mechanic who is good at marine engines does not want to get into the subject. So given the expense and possibility to mess things up I am a bit cautious, reason why I started this thread to find out if there are ANY outdrives with closed cooling out there.

Given the lack of positive response, I conclude there are NO outdrives with closed cooling. Chris Craft does not seem to have offered the option for outdrives...

...And this bears some reason. What the inboard people on this forum may not realize is that a Q engine sits extremely close to the transom. The outdrive's steering tiller swings in between the risers and there would be NO room for the thermostat housing, associated plumbing, and never mind a heat exchanger, between the risers, the tiller and the transom as Chris Craft has it in their own Closed Cooling system. The picture below of my engine shows how tight things are.

Chris Craft possibly did not want to have yet another cooling system for the Q with outdrive configuration, so outdrive boats were produced with the standard Q raw water system only. My theory, I would love to be proved wrong.

Henry, if you want to email me ( pitjean1"at"gmail.com ) we can share other ideas on this.. Thanks.

-X9am6Xez9r3ZXm1WpCC8AdAbTZfSfyuUXWsMn8fYiRq06F58IqX4x2QRGuSV_b6KBeyQYasNCmJrfMwJsGT--sXn1nRQger4PWhKTD5YQrVQqLbo9PBsLm_MVs6zqpN88U5Gfq-wg



 
 Respond to this message   

Contact the Chris Craft Commander Forum
chriscraftcommander@hotmail.com

©2005, ©2006, ©2007, ©2008, ©2009, ©2010, ©2010, ©2011, ©2012, ©2013, ©2014, ©2015, ©2016, ©2017, ©2018, Chris-Craft Commander Forum, Inc., ®, also known as ChrisCraftCommander.com. and the Chris Craft Commander Forum, Inc.; Information and intellectual property on this not-for-profit non-commercial site may be copied for individual personal use, but any other reproduction or use requires written approval. Any entity who mines this site for names, material, or their other commercial/financial benefit in any way is subject to copyright and intellectual property law; the integrity of this site will be aggressively protected. The material here is for individual personal use and is not to be otherwise used or reproduced. Chris Craft is a registered trademark of Chris-Craft. Neither Chris-Craft nor any subsidiaries of Chris-Craft shall bear any responsibility for the chriscraftcommander.com content, comments, or advertising. Chris-Craft Commander Forum, Inc., is independent from Chris-Craft Corporation, and not affiliated with the Chris-Craft Commander Club in any way; it is an independent educational-based not-for-profit entity that is intended to share free information and have fun. Copyright/trademark/sales mark infringements are not intended, or implied.