answers

my Rogue in melee setup:

AC 389
to hit close to 300%
damage 110-140 or thereabouts
mana 450ish
life 270ish

items:

Tulkas
Godly/opacity FPM
Wyrm zod and Hydra zod rings
obs heavens necklace
StormSh
Two Winters(sucks mana)

and she is kicking A LOT of ass even in hell/hell...due to perfect blocking.. not many things can touch me...and if i get toa corner, they cant kill me via melee since only 3 can hit me at a time:) and i suck mana:)

so based on personal experience, s/s rogue is VERY feasible.. but a bow is still better:)

PSY