Somebody pls clue me in on why the furious bidding on this one?
The generic back itself, for #15, isn't rare -- but is specific issue for July 14, 1935 (14735 in lower righthand corner) a difficult one?
(Disclaimer: I don't accept that old saw about "147th day" of 1935 . . . think it's been wrong from the start, when it was first suggested. No company would decide to use such a weird numbering system. My opinion remains that the lower righthand reference numbers, on back, can all be understood as the more common day/month/year or, rarely, month/day/year.)
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.
Re: eBay Lot, Heinz Airplanes Card - Art Deco Version
No score for this post
August 31 2008, 7:24 PM
I have no idea why this card has garnered such interest - and as a shameless promo, I have LOTS of these available, in better condition, for the limited price of $50 per (haha).
As for product date coding; I've a fairly good understanding of the CPG marketplace, and MANY of these companies use similar production codes. For example, Masterfoods (M&M/Mars) places the production week into their code (as well as line information), so that 814AG3 tells you that the item was produced on the 14th week of 2008. And for recall purposes, most lot numbers have some date specific information.
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.
I concur that is a production date code in the lower righthand corner of the card's back, but feel we as a hobby have misinterpretted it so far. "14735" doesn't mean 147th day of 1935 but, rather (my opinion) means the production date of 14-7-35 (14 July 1935).
(Somewhere, sometime, some wise man said that usually the simplest explanation tends to be the correct one!)
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.
I'd proffer that the 1st digit can't be the month (0969), nor could the digit 3rd from last (32236). It seems most logical that for the years 1934-1937, the code is DDDYY; and for the years 1938 & 1939, the code is DDDY.
BUT - it doesn't matter - PSA has already decreed that the issue dates for the Heinz cards are 1938 (Famous Aviators) and 1940 (Famous Airplanes)
This message has been edited by Mark_Finn on Aug 31, 2008 7:52 PM
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.
Re: eBay Lot, Heinz Airplanes Card - Art Deco Version
No score for this post
August 31 2008, 11:09 PM
I'm thinking that, with just a little bit of leniency, the "Day/Month/Year" or "Month/Day/Year" patterns work for all the card back production code numbers.
So, why might it sometimes switch? Well, first of all, things were surely a lot more loosey-goosey back then, compared to today's rigid ISO 14000 etc. controls and standardization of manufacturing processes.
And regardless of the era, anybody who's ever worked in a company run by PEOPLE already partly understands, especially when talking about irregularities in a process which occurred over a 5-year period. Long time to screw around. (One guy likes to date-stamp the cards/albums in one way, the other, another way . . . and a third, his own way, e.g. 0969! Who knows?) But lack of consistency certainly wouldn't be enough reason, to me, to reject this more familiar way to write production dates.)
The "either/or" hypothesis works and can generate a date (sometimes two) for each production code:
3238 - 3 Feb 38 or Mar 2 38
9836 - 9 Aug 36 or Sep 8 36
9935 - 9 Sep 35
13137 - 13 Jan 37 or Jan 31 37
14636 - 14 Jun 36
14735 - 14 Jul 35
22738 - 22 Jul 38 or Feb 27 38
23235 - 23 Feb 35
27434 - 27 Apr 34
32236 - Mar 22 36
0969 - 9 Jun (3)9 or Sep 6 (3)9
I admit, the fact that some of these generate two potential dates makes me uncomfortable with this hypothesis, but I just don't see the layout artist or printer countings days to determine the "232nd Day of 1935" . . . Seems overly precise, for their purposes.
. . . As Papa Dan might say, "How long you wanna discuss and debate this? How long you got?)
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.
Ralph, agree in general with your DD/MM/YR rather than any other, but have a problem with 32236. It seems all others (#'s) have the day first, the month then the year. The 32236 only works with MM/DD/YR theory. A few of the others work both ways but only this one works with the second formula, why would Heinz switch for this one and revert back on the others? It just doesn't make sense to jump back and forth.
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.
Re: eBay Lot, Heinz Airplanes Card - Art Deco Version
No score for this post
September 6 2008, 7:54 PM
Well the auction ended and went for nearly 100.00 as a new bidder sniped at the end only to come up short. So 3 different bidders bid at least 63.99. It appears the winner is not a card collector, but an aviation buff.
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.
Re: eBay Lot, Heinz Airplanes Card - Art Deco Version
No score for this post
September 6 2008, 8:32 PM
Bill, I like your observation that the 'European' style for dates [ Day Month Year ] works for all cases, but one. This would be consistent with a scenario where that was Heinz's standard and that single variation was an accident -- employee mistakenly using the more familiar American style [ Month Day Year ].
Richard, now that the dust has settled, perhaps one of the bidders can step forward and explain to us what all the hubbub was about. Was this rarer than the others? (Have we done a census of the number variations yet?)
This message has been edited by 30s_non-sport_gum on Sep 6, 2008 8:33 PM
Scoring disabled. You must be logged in to score posts.
Current Topic - eBay Lot, Heinz Airplanes Card - Art Deco Version