I tried out the Ping Craz-E putter yesterday for about an hour at the Golf USA store here on their pretty good putting surface, stroking 12 footers. The Craz-E was a little heavier than I expected, which is good. It set up pretty well, and the wide base makes sure you get it flush to the surface, which is also good. I did not care much for the hosel bend or the point of attachment of the hosel, as it affected the way the putter moves thru the impact area in a way that didn't feel right to me, but that may just be me.
Visually, the width of the rectangle behind the sweetspot was very nice for squaring thru the ball. I believe this visual feature is more important than the central "line" that the website crows about as better than the Odyssey Two-Ball (which has no line). I'm not sure whether I liked or disliked the blue half-ball shape at the rear of the rectangle, coordinated inside a full-ball metal shape and matched with a half-ball shape at the back of the putter face nearest the ball. I felt that ball stuff had more to do with registering the motion of the putter thru the impact area in peripheral vision than with alignment of the face at address. I did not like the odd, floral-shaped "holes" on the near and far sides of the putter head, but they seemed to help the stroke motion hand-eye coordination visually in the same motion arena near impact as seen peripherally. Not sure about this yet.
The extent of the putter head front to back had a little effect on the bottom of the stroke. Going away from the ball, it seems to discourage lifting the putter head (good) and to encourage a nice relaxed slide back by virtue of a shoulder rock pushing the triangle back away from the ball. On the thru-stroke, however, it felt like the center of gravity was well behind impact with the ball, and this makes you feel the impact dynamic is slightly hands-ahead without a clear signal when to send the shoulder frame up. I haven't had enough experience with this effect yet to say whether I liked it or disliked it, but there was a distinct dynamic thru impact that made the putter work best.
The putter rolled balls pretty smoothly, but it seemed a little tricky to me to get all the putts on the same line. I compared the Ping Craz-E to other putters along the wall, including the Bobby Grace MOI putter, the TaylorMade TPi 25, and an old Ram FX heel-shafted blade. Compared to the results I got from these putters using the same stroke, the Ping Craz-E did not come off so well. It seemed to take an extra effort to hone in on what the putter required for stroke action to get the putts all rolling the same direction. Maybe it's just me, but then again the other putters I tried at the same time were very deadly.
I suspect that putters like the Two-Ball and the Craz-E, with their prominent alignment markings, provide a good improvement for many amateurs with indifferent targeting skills to begin with. This plus probably colors the golfers' attitude to the other features of the putter in judging performance characteristics. Personally, I find the visual busy-ness and over-sized head and sole distracting.
But I'll keep messing with it.
Cheers!
Geoff Mangum
Putting Theorist and Instructor
Geoff Mangum's PuttingZone
Golf's most advanced and comprehensive putting instruction.
Over 625,000 visits and growing strong ...
518 Woodlawn Ave
Greensboro NC 27401
336.230.0612 home
336.402.1602 cell