Dear Tom,
Go ahead and tighten your grip a smidgen and also your general arm muscle tone but stay focused on the straightness of the movement of the putter face thru impact and a little past.
Use the Don Pooley drill I describe in the
Practice>Drills for Skills section of MyTips on the website starting about 3-4 feet out with a straight putt and then move back to about 5 feet. Make a dozen or more putts this way, then remove the Don Pooley "gate" and make the putts au naturel with the same sort of movement the "gate" teaches.
Missing to the right is an ambiguous diagnostic sign but often means that when you setup and then look from ball to target, you shift the top of your head back and this rotates the base of your neck off line to the right / outside for a right-hander. The putt then follows the base of the neck, regardless of where the eyes say the putt "should" go. So pay a little attention to setting your eyes so the line across the eyes matches the line of the putt. This "skull line" or "eye line" (as some call it) includes permanent bone features in the skull -- top of ears, temples, outside corners of eye sockets, inside corners of eye sockets, bridge of nose -- and also includes the pupils of the eyeballs, but only when the eyeballs are aimed / gazing straight out of the face to match this skull line. If you set the skull line to match the putt line, this sets the base of the neck square to the putt and also sets the shoulders square or parallel to the putt. When you pull the trigger, this should not have gotten changed off line by looking to the target.
If missing these putts is really a touch issue, then tightening the arms and grip a little will translate into a shorter stroke that would leave the putt short if you don't increase your tempo. So a tighter, quicker stroke is the desired combination. Even so, still just move ONLY the lead shoulder socket, just a shorter motion and a quicker motion, but still straight down and back along the balls of the feet, and back to level and up further and back a little. A nice one-two count as you putt will probably help.
Cheers!
Geoff Mangum
Putting Theorist and Instructor
Geoff Mangum's PuttingZone
Golf's most advanced and comprehensive putting instruction.
Over 625,000 visits and growing strong ...
518 Woodlawn Ave
Greensboro NC 27401
336.230.0612 home
336.402.1602 cell