SMRC , we have never had male factor issues . So I do not think I am in anyway qualified to an opinion in this matter . Yet I have been on this other boards for a long time ( 6 OE cycles) . My feeling is that poor sperm quality is much more manageable with ICSI/IMSI vs poor egg quality . Like the other poster I have also seen success stories with improvement in sperm quality with supplements . In your position I would probably go to a lab with excellent ICSI/IMSI and do the supplements and use donor egg . Good luck .