Hi there and welcome!
There is a search function in the upper right corner you may wish to check out as there has been a lot of past discussion, and it would be very informative.
I would also encourage you to define what is most important and go from there. If you go with an agency or a clinic with an in house donor pool, there is absolutely no reason to stay local...especially regarding agencies. I think you would want to find an agency which a good reputation for honesty and with a pool of donors you like, or a clinic with good stats and some donors you like.
I also do not know your history, so if you are less complicated in terms of ttc, you have a wider field of clinics to choose from (I need an RI, so I am more limited, though happy to be limited to my RE).
I have posted a lot regarding my thoughts on agencies as I had a very difficult time this past year and found people repeatedly misrepresenting information to me. You can find my opinions under the search. I did an extensive search as we wanted certain things verified, and I feel there are only a handful of agencies who are trustworthy. Not that the rest are flat out dishonest, but different people and different agencies have differing senses of what disclosure is.