Peter - "Since Hogan raised his heel in some swings and didn't in others you will need to decide which aesthetic you prefer or look into the reasons for the difference."
It's interesting that here in this DG we are now discussing an aspect of the swing that has been debated many times here regarding the Moe swing - though more often it was about Moe's trail foot being flat or not. The pure NG'rs and Graves insisting Moe's trail foot was flat, though young and old Moe swings clearly show it rolls.
Peter's point is a good one...look to the reasons why one would let the heel come up on some swings and not on other swings. I have pics of Tiger making all out swings with irons when his back foot remains flat and also when it doesn't.
Herbert's post from The Five is instructive also. Anthony has stated that for now his only goal is to emulate Hogan aesthetically...so he is good to go either way.
The Authentic Golfer
A Blueprint For Golf Excellence
Never quit til you have a swing you'll never forget!